MovieChat Forums > 4: Rise of the Silver Surfer (2007) Discussion > Highly underrated.

Highly underrated.

posted 14 years ago by StarBored214
52 replies | jump to latest

I am shocked to see that both critics and users do not care for this film. Yes it suffers the same faulty features of the first film, such as Tim Story's direction and illogical dialogue, but it is fairly entertaining. It contains nicely done action sequences and a nice subplot with the whole altering powers. Many will disagree, but I thought, at least compared to the first, it's a very good picture.

R.I.P Chris Hemsworth's Career
Born: "Star Trek"
Died: "Thor"

[–] 12 years ago

[deleted]

[–] petarostoja1982 11 years ago

I had to post, just to say to StarBored214:
Your signature has to be, like the single,most irritating thing I have ever read on IMDB, and that is saying a lot!!!
Born:Star Drek
Died:Thor???????????????

But moviewise, you are right. It is an underrated film!!!
It is much better than the first.

[–] davidlau17 11 years ago

Nah, it is what it is. Stupid, sometimes mildly entertaining.

[–] beat 11 years ago

dear OP, how can a movie that you describe this way:

Yes it suffers the same faulty features of the first film, such as Tim Story's direction and illogical dialogue, but it is fairly entertaining.

be "highly underrated"?

[–] 11 years ago

[deleted]

[–] 11 years ago

[deleted]

[–] DamianGein 10 years ago

It was certainly better than the first one. It improved a lot. I wouldn't call it highly underrated though. It was just OK.

Esta es mi firma

[–] brianwhite5 10 years ago

I agree it's very highly underrated like it's older brother. I have both movies on blu ray and watch them at least twice a year - they're great for cheering one up.