MovieChat Forums > Ratatouille (2007) Discussion > Boring, unfunny and very overrated

Boring, unfunny and very overrated


The movie just doesn't take you anywhere at all. Paris is a city with so many amazing sights, pity the movie is stuck in a tight kitchen the whole time. It gives off the impression it needs major fleshing out, like it's an animation prototype or something. There's just nothing to it. The only character that caught my eye was the food critic, the rest are too realistic. I can't think of a single time I was close to laughing. A pleasant movie to watch, but after seeing what Pixar can do, I was disappointed. It just seems like a film can do well simply because it's made by someone who's produced masterpieces, not because of its actual experience.

reply

I'm sorry, but I don't think you quite comprehended this movie. In fact, it's brilliant, interesting and pretty funny at times (although that's subjective of course) and IMO underrated (it should be much higher on imdb's list).

--
''Most illogical.''

reply

I respect your opinion because well, to each their own. I absolutely love this movie! When I first heard about it I rolled my eyes and thought, disgusting, a rat cooking in a kitchen. Everyone was raving about this movie and I thought it was overrated. But then I watched it about a week ago (I know I'm a couple years late) I now agree with everyone who says it's such a wonderful movie!

I love food and I think it was absolutely gorgeous. PIXAR is known for their animation skills and I believe that it was really good in this movie. Maybe not the best, in your eyes and many others but it wasn't disgustingly ugly. I love Remy's character but I couldn't really stand the little chef, Colette, or Linguini. Just Remy, his family of rats and the critic.

The story line was very original and I felt that we saw enough of Paris to know that it was set in Paris but didn't really revolve around Paris. Basically it was all about Remy finding his passion and ultimately achieving his goal. I think the reason I watch it over and over is when he cooks the ratatouille.

Also to the person who said that Remy just came from the sewer and jumped everywhere through the pots and pans .. did you not notice that right away he was chucked into the sink where all the dishes were and then he came out, rolled around in the restaurant (mind you he's pretty clean by now). Then when he begins to throw ingredients in the soup he jumps on the sink, grabs a glob of water and washes his hands with it. If you were paying attention to the movie, you'd see this and know he's not a dirty rat. And also when the whole family cooks with him they all go into that thing that pushes out steam and is probably meant to clean something or other.

All in all, I'd give it about a 9.5/10. That's my honest opinion and I believe other critics found this to be a nice PIXAR movie. Not everyone is suppose to love it but that doesn't mean a lot of people won't.

reply

I'll take the overly simplistic and tasteless criticism of the previous posters with a grain of salt as it matters not to me that my perspective cannot garner a universally agreeable consensus. And as such, consider this my own personal review:

I have to admit, it was a tad dull in the beginning, as dictates the custom of any decent film attempting to familiarize us with the characters, emphasizing their importance throughout the film. Surprisingly enough, this comes at no expense of clever dialogue; the commentary was writhe with wit and gave the audience an honest insight to each to each character's motivation and purpose. For instance, as the bumbling new chef and garbage boy, Linguini, attempts to introduce himself to the experienced, but tempered Colette, he is met with a quick knife to the sleeve, pinning him to the table. From there, we receive a tongue-lashing monologue where Colette schools the young rookie on his place in the kitchen and makes it clear she is determined to tutor him for her sake more than his own. As rocky a start as this is, the two surprisingly develop a sweet romance throughout the film, tested by the lies and secrets having a rat as an assistant chef would garner.

Remy himself is plagued with his own set of dilemmas; his loved ones don't share his passion and he's forced to pursue it in a dangerous world where prejudice against his species is almost inherent and finds unlikely aid in an awkward human companion completely by chance. In partnership, they attempt to defy their lowly reputations by restoring glory to a once-successful restaurant. I cannot express enough how much I appreciate the development of this dynamic, especially in sidestepping the cliches of most animated features by exchanging campiness for cleverness.

In short, this movie was compelling in a way no one expected it to be. It shares with us the tried and true message of pursuing a passion, regardless of the circumstances and obstacles, from an entirely new perspective. The conventions of previous animated classics are still yet present (an unlikely partnership, anthropomorphic animals, the genius/dimwit duo, and many more), but have been altered with due respect to modern cultural relevance and breaking the mold to shift our mindset from what we expect to anything they can imagine.

9.5/10

reply

[deleted]

You people have sticks up your arses. Pixar tried something different with this movie and it's a shame that so many people are like "AAHHH OH NO AN ANIMATED FILM THAT ISN'T *FUNNY*!".

---
Why don't presidents fight the war? -SOAD

reply

I love this movie. Its a great movie about the finer things in life. Disappointed that it doesn't show of Paris? That want really the point of the movie. It wasn't about sightseeing, it was about cooking
There are a lot of other movies out there that show off Paris, try one of them


Yes, its not funny, but then again, does it have to be funny? Is there a rule anywhere that Pixar movies, or animated for that matter must be funny?
Its more of a light drama, but its still much better than a lot of movies today.

reply

the sooner general audiences realize that animation is not strictly for comedy, the better. Ratatouille could have easily been on Oscar's short list of nominees for best motion picture of 2007.

reply

Yes, because Up, WALL-E and Toy Story 3 were all such big laugh riots.
Face it, some people dislike this film based on its own merits, not out of a misconception of it being a failed comedy.

Supermodels...spoiled stupid little stick figures mit poofy lips who sink only about zemselves.

reply

Fair point, MetFanMac. I'm just talking about the people who did expect a big laugh riot from Ratatouille. (Also, I recall being kind of angry when I wrote that. : P)

---
Mother, do you think they'll like this song?

reply

I completely disagree - I think it's a fabulous film, funny and touching at the same time, a very sharp script and peerless animation 10/10.

reply

[deleted]

I guess because the story is told from Remy's point of view, we can't expect too many of Paris' amazing sights. The tight kitchen from your perspective is everything Remy needs to see in his life. He's a rat. He expects less. We're humans. we expect too much.

reply

[deleted]