MovieChat Forums > Salinui chueok (2003) Discussion > Memories of Murder vs Zodiac

Memories of Murder vs Zodiac


Which one do you think is better? Two are quite similar and based on true story.

reply

Ha, I also picked up on the similarity.

Memories of Murder for me, but Zodiac was very well made. I just think there was a terrific mystique and bleakness portrayed here.

reply

Zodiac`s a fine film - Fincher`s best AFAIK - but there`s something about MOM`s aesthetic as well as the thick vein of absurdist humor that elevates it higher. It`s such a complete movie, this Korean one, featuring all the perks of a policier while also offering deeper textures. Zodiac 8-8,5/10 vs MOM 9/10.



"facts are stupid things" - Ronald Reagan

reply

Memories of Murder is much better.

reply

Memories of Murder..

I do feel at times that True Detective was influenced by it but I don't have any source to confirm that. It's quite similar in a way. The cold eerie setting far away from the city and the characters themselves have quite something in common.

reply

This is a toss up but I give a slight nod to Memories of Murder.

reply

Zodiac is much better...

reply

Memories of Murder

Esta es mi firma


reply

It reminded me more of Se7en.
All three films are fantastic.

reply

Memories for me. Though i think Zodiac was better that portraying the suspects and making you question them more than Memories did.

reply