MovieChat Forums > The Notebook (2004) Discussion > What is the greatest love story of all t...

What is the greatest love story of all time?

posted 16 years ago by DrFilmCritic
314 replies | jump to latest

?

Like to Subscribe for Film News (Especially if you like Ryan Gosling <3)
http://FilmLedger.com/

[–] moonlight100 15 years ago

Pride and Prejudice? Probably one of the most overrated book/movies of all time.
1. When Harry Met Sally
2. Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind
3. Titanic
4. Annie Hall
5. A Room With a View
6. Bridges of Madison County(Book not movie)
7. Moulin Rouge
8. Gone with the Wind
9. Ethan Frome (Book not movie)
10.Spiderman
I think the Notebook is a tad overrated....the only good scene is when he takes her in the bog/lake with the swans and trees.

[–] arkast 15 years ago

the notebook seemed great when i saw it for the first time but seemed boring the second time and not so good

[–] Liz_Lemler 15 years ago

Twilight....

JUST KIDDING

Definitely Casablanca.

For British eyes only

[–] fiveforme 15 years ago

I agree with the 12 posters who said Gone With The Wind.

I agree with the 4 posters who said When Harry Met Sally.

I agree with Prom Queen Carrie who said The Way We Were.

To susico: I'm sorry that this is a "tragic love story", but I'm really surprised that no one mentioned Love Story. Watching it in 2010 shows horrible acting by Ali MacGraw, but in 1970 it was the ultimate love story.

To Mikaela90:, you said "The Notebook, I mean, I love this movie mostly for the parts between the old couple". If anyone else agrees that this is the best part of The Notebook, you absolutely have to watch Away From Her with Gordon Pinsent and Julie Christie. It has a similar storyline as the older Allie and Noah. And if The Notebook made you cry, make sure you have the tissues ready for Away From Her.

[–] Mepark 15 years ago

No love story, not even this great one, comes even close to the greatest one of all: MESSAGE IN A BOTTLE, coincidentally by the same writer.

[–] almanik 15 years ago

Honestly the most natural and relate able love story I have ever seen was found in 'Real Life', it's a very thought provoking series.

[–] emmacaton1993 15 years ago

The Phantom of the opera, definatly

Dream as if you'll live forever, live as if you'll die today

[–] rachel-marie44 15 years ago

Your own :)

[–] mala_education 15 years ago

I'm a bit unconventional so to me the greatest love story is Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind because it's honest. Love isn't perfect and people tend to forget that and it takes true love to stay with someone despite their imperfections and neuroticisms. Also Before Sunrise/Sunset are great love stories and of course the Notebook.

Looking for a good film??http://malaeducation.blogspot.com/

[–] 15 years ago

[deleted]

[–] osu12 15 years ago

Titanic. The Notebook is GREAT, but it just doesn't have the deep passion and tragedy that Titanic does.

HAHA MADE YA LOOK! Btw,I'm done with my post now

Or am I?

[–] nikilove9 15 years ago

"Endless Love" and "Gone With The Wind"

[–] cdz6969 15 years ago

Clerks - "There's a million fine looking women in the world, dude. But, they don't all bring you lasagna at work. Most of 'em just cheat on you."

This is for Allah... and it's going way out there sucka...

[–] 15 years ago

[deleted]