top 5 western

my top western are #1 once upon a time in the west #2 the good the bad and ugly # 3 open range # 4 the searchers # 5 high noon # 6 3.10 to yuma #7 butch cassidy and sundance kid # 8 wyatt earp # 9 shane #10 the great silence # 11 rio bravo # 12 red sun #13 they call me trinity #14 for few dollars more # 15 duel in the sun and the magnificent seven ....

That's because Tombstone SUCKS!!!, it's an overrated piece sh!t(that needs to be flushed down the toilet) with crappy writing and horrible acting, Russell is terrible as a gold digging whiney sissy Earp, Paxton was a huge miscast, Dana Dalaney is just plain stupid as a woman whose only goal in life is to have room service, and John Tenney is horrible. The only good thing about the film is Val Kilmer, and that's not enough to make up for what's so bad about the film.

"Don't mind me, man, I'm just effen with ya…" - Janis Joplin

Open Range
A Fistful of Dollars
Tombstone
Ride With The Devil
McLintock!
The Shootist
True Grit
North to Alaska
Dead Man
Go West (got to put one comedy in there)

Yojimbo - No, it's not set in the American west. No, it's not in English. No, it doesn't have cowboys or Indians. But this movie was inspired by American Westerns, and if you watch it, you'll see that it captures the feel of a Western better than almost any other movie that was ever made. If you've seen A Fistful Of Dollars, you know the story, and I think Yojimbo does it a little better, and did it first.

And finally, Deadwood. Television has rarely been better. childintime-1, your analysis of the characterization, acting, and plot of this fine show could not be farther off the mark.

[deleted]