Natalie is "fat"??

To be fair, Hugh Grant's character agrees with you and he's the one you're supposed to be rooting for.

I imagine it was kind of a difficult thing to try to do. She's called chubby by a couple characters yet the person that the story is about doesn't think she's fat. So how big or small should the actress be? One thing that people seem to ignore is that we aren't meant to agree with the people calling her fat, we're meant to agree with the Prime Minister.

She's not fat, but slim probably wouldn't bring up a mental image of her body type in many, in any, peoples minds.


If she knocked on my door she'd get in, but if someone asked me to describe her body I'd probably say height weight proportionate, but I wouldn't say slim, or svelt, or say she was a stick or athletic looking, etc.



If You're Failing to Plan,
You're Planning to Fail.

[deleted]

she's not fat, but not as skinny as most of the other young women in the film. And Hugh grant clearly likes her.

Agree. That black lady who worked for Hugh's character was so rude (sizeable thighs) ugh

It was a very accurate scene. The girl thought she was chubby and you could see why she would say that. Hugh disagreed and that was his POV. It was a very accurate scene.

I agree with the OP. It's ridiculous to consider her fat or chubby.

Yes. That said, she was "good" fat.

"If you want to improve, be content to be thought foolish and stupid."