MovieChat Forums > Lizzie McGuire (2001) Discussion > Lizzie McGuire or Hannah Montana?

Lizzie McGuire or Hannah Montana?


I would go more Lizzie McGuire...i grew up watching this show and can defiantly relate to it more. At least at that age. and miley cyrus is pretty annoying. what about you guys?


Buster: No mother, I can blow myself. You've interfered for the last time.

reply

Lizze 110 times over. Hannah is annoying.

http://amandabynesnews.blogspot.com

reply

Well, i like them both, but i think Lizzie McGuire is more about how Middle school is and Hannah Montana is about being a rockstar. I'm 13 years old and i watched both shows but yeah. They both are kinda similar because Miley Cyrus is probably gonna turn out like Hilary Duff, singing after Hannah Montanna is over.

Dinosaurs go rawr

reply

[deleted]

Lizzie McGuire by far.
Hannah Montana alone is pathetic, Miley is stupid, and together they are retarded.
I hate Miley, I wish she never became famous! She's so dumb! And if any of you Miley fans listened to her patheticness when she was on Kiss FM, you would think she was the most retarded girl you've ever heard of.

*throws Skittles at you* TASTE THE FREAKIN' RAINBOW!

reply

HANNAH MONTANA!
:]]

and I grew up watching Lizzie McGuire, too, and I definitely choose Hannah.

A true friend knows the song in your heart and sings it to you when you forget the words:)

reply

Hannah Montana Is Awesome

No ordinary human is perfect...Obviously I wasnt counting my self as ordinary

reply

Lizzie McGuire...Hannah Montana was created by Disney because they noticed they didnt have enough teenage stars at the moment so they grabbed a has-beens daughter. She cant sing live if you havent noticed and Hilary Duff can.......The mother whos daughter wrote a false essay....thats what Disney's created...True, they made Hilary Duff happen, but they werent desperate back then, hilary has real talent.

reply

Too easy. Lizzie McGuire!

The opposite of was isn't peace...it's creation.

reply

That's obvious: Lizzie McGuire.

While Hilary Duff is far from a good actor, she deserves an Oscar in comparison to Miley Cyrus. At least Hilary Duff could deliver her lines and sound like she actually knew what the hell she was saying. We also didn't have to deal with that deer in headlights look that Miley always gives.

Plus, Lizzie McGuire didn't have annoying catchphrases (thank you "Raven," for that). I swear, if I hear, "Say what," one more time while flipping through channels, I'm going to pull my hair out.

Furthermore, Lizzie's friends weren't complete idiots. They were normal. Like friends we had. And, most importantly, I could relate to Lizzie McGuire. LM dealt with the stuff normal girls dealt with or were going to deal with - buying your first bra, having to realize that you don't change who you are for a guy you like, first love, getting a job, the need for independence from parents, bar/bat mitzvahs, first kisses, eating disorders, etc. LM always had a clear message, the jokes were never forced, and it was a family show. It's impossible to relate to Hannah Montana. She's a girl, just like me, only she's a pop star, lives in a huge house in Malibu, dates movie stars who fall from the sky (literally), and has no clue WHAT she'll do if she can't go to her huge, all star party. Not once has HM dealt with things that normal girls go through.

To this day I can still watch Lizzie McGuire, laugh, smile, and enjoy myself. I feel sick when I watch Hannah Montana. It's not well written, it's not well acted (save for Emily Osment, but her character is so annoying it doesn't really matter), it's not relatable, and it's just not good.

Sorry for that long rant. Ever since Disney canceled its last good shows (Phil of the Future and Kim Possible), I've had huge issues with the channel. *Sigh* Oh well. At least I can still watch LM, Sister Sister, and Even Stevens on WGN.

"Bye, Harry!" said Hermione, and she [...] kissed him on the cheek.

reply

HANNAH MONTANA x100000

reply

lizzy, i could relate to her, shes a regular quirky girl









YOu KILLED MY BROTHER GEORGE YOU BASTARD!!LETS SEE YOU NOW!LETS SEE U NOW!

reply

[deleted]