Obi-Wan vs. Anakin -- Why does he just walk away instead of finishing him off?


During the climactic battle between master and student, Anakin's legs are chopped off, after which he proceeds to catch on fire and begins burning alive. While it may seem safe to assume that a normal human would not survive such an ordeal, it's still incredibly illogical that Obi-Wan would, at this point, choose to merely turn and walk away. Instead of quickly confirming the kill, he decides to leave Anakin laying helplessly on the ground, but still breathing.

First, Anakin is NOT a normal human, but a powerful Jedi. Such Jedis typically seem to be able to withstand much more damage than the average guy. Perhaps more importantly, though, Obi-Wan and Anakin had a very close relationship--they were practically family. Even if Obi-Wan was in fact certain Anakin was finished, you'd think the master would still want to go over and quickly put his former Jedi "brother" out of his misery (via decapitation or whatever other means necessary).

Ultimately, the way the scene plays out is doubly nonsensical--Obi-Wan allowing Anakin to suffer a potentially slow, extremely painful death, while simultaneously (and foolishly) providing Anakin a chance to survive. Which of course he does.

I realize this is a common trope in movies, where the hero basically assumes the villain is dead instead of properly finishing him off. But it particularly stuck out to me here because of the multi-faceted silliness of the whole thing.

And yes, I also understand that Anakin needed to survive in order for the original Star Wars story to exist. Surely, though, the scene could have been written a bit less lazily and still found a way to produce the same outcome.

Then again, if I'm misinterpreting something here, please let me know.

reply

I think Obi Wan would rather let him die than finish him off, after all Anakin was like a brother to him , there's an emotional attachment , if there wasn't , perhaps he would of finished him off.

reply

The emotional attachment is exactly what makes Obi-Wan's decision more illogical to me. If it was someone he truly hated, I could understand leaving him there to slowly burn to death. But with Anakin being like a brother to him, I'd think Obi-Wan would want to end his suffering as quickly as possible.

I realize delivering the final death blow would be a difficult thing to do, but an experienced Jedi master such as Obi-Wan should surely have the capacity to do it.

reply

Yes, Obi-Wan was just recently jabbing that lightsaber at Anakin in a way that would surely kill him if Anakin didn't defend himself.

reply

I suppose the obvious answer (though it may not satisfy) is that Obi-Wan was in such anguish over having to kill Anakin to begin with -- remember he even warned Anakin at the very end not to make that final leap, coupled with the assumption that Anakin was already "dead."

He would have been right --in the assumption that Anakin would proceed to die -- had not Palpatine arrived just in time to save the day for Anakin.

Perhaps Obi-Wan thought Yoda did his job and he wouldn't have to worry about a Palpatine intervention.

reply

I can certainly understand Obi-Wan's anguish over having to kill Anakin; it just seems like that anguish would be much greater letting him die a slow, painful death, as opposed to a quick mercy killing.

Regarding the possible assumptions by Obi-Wan, I find it hard to believe that a wise Jedi knight such as himself would have even made them. A true Jedi master would leave nothing to chance in that situation, especially considering the incredible importance of its final outcome.

Of course, I suppose anyone can make a mistake.

reply

Your points are well taken.

If I wanted to belabor a defense of Obi-Wan I could suggest that Anakin was so close to death that endorphins and shock would have mitigated suffering before his demise, so Obi-Wan walked away thinking that Anakin would be dead in a few moments and save him from making that final death stroke and hearing the screams and curses that would haunt him later.

It's been awhile, but I think, upon his arrival, Palpatine said something like "hurry - we don't have much time (to save Anakin)?" Underscoring that idea.

But to your point, given what transpired afterward, Obi-Wan should have finished the job. Perhaps it's just another case of human (Jedi) error in judgement and ultimately there is no defense.

reply

Fair point about Anakin's shock potentially mitigating his suffering. I am by no means an expert in such things, but I believe I've read somewhere that burning to death is literally the most painful way a person can die. Whether or not that's actually true, it may have played some subconscious role in adding to my surprise regarding Obi-Wan's decision to leave his old friend in such a state.

You are correct about Palpatine's arrival onto the scene--I believe the exact line was something like: "He's still alive; get a medical capsule immediately." But yeah, same idea. I do kind of wonder exactly how much time had elapsed between Obi-Wan's departure and Palpatine's arrival, considering at the one point flames were fully engulfing Anakin, and then completely extinguished at the next. Must have been a hell of an ordeal for Anakin to endure, which I suppose helps explain his ultimate transformation into Vader.

Either way, I'd agree that my whole issue with the scene likely boils down to a simple error in judgement.

reply

Obi Wan had to walk away instead of finishing him off because we all know Anakin would live on and wear the Darth Vadar costume. If Obi Wan would have killed him, that would be a plot hole for the next movie when he appears again

reply

I realize you're just trolling, but I actually addressed that point in my OP.

For Christ's sake, man, put a little effort into it!

reply

nooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo

ahem

reply

Ultimately, the way the scene plays out is doubly nonsensical--Obi-Wan allowing Anakin to suffer a potentially slow, extremely painful death, while simultaneously (and foolishly) providing Anakin a chance to survive. Which of course he does.

I think Obi Wan represents the "good" in humanity - the willingness to not take life. Obi-Wan realises that Anakin is defeated, yet he can't and will not follow through on ending his friend, it would be like killing one's son. Obi Wan's actions represent appeasement, an emotional action.

reply