MovieChat Forums > A Time to Kill (1996) Discussion > The most powerful line I've heard in a f...

The most powerful line I've heard in a film.


At the end, when he's summing up his case. He tells them to close their eyes as he's describing what happened to the little girl, then he says "now imagine she was white".

It's so emotive. I think the case would be lost without him saying that. They were all of the same racial mentality. This made the little girl the same as one of their daughters instead of 'some black kid that doesn't matter' .

Great writing.

reply

I was already seeing her as white

reply

You must not have seen too many movies. I can think of a more powerful line in just about every movie I own.

The truth is this movie is so wrong, it’s saying there are circumstances where it’s ok to murder someone in handcuffs on the way to their trial, that is setting such a dangerous precedent

The trial had nothing to do with the girl who was assaulted, it was about not letting people decided to become the judge, jury and executioner by themselves, no one should be allowed to do that. If it’s ok to murder a rapist in cold blood then one day it’s going to be you on the other end of that rifle

reply

I agree with you completely! It's made even more sad because that is the mind frame so many live in :(

reply

I would put a white guy in jail too, if he decided to kill people and turn an innocent man into an amputee.

reply

That scene ruined the entire film for me. He already had the jury in tears with the description of the events. The jury should have gasped in disgust when he slapped them with that condescending and judgemental comment.

reply

In the book one of the jurors said that to the others doing deliberation. Of course they have to give that line to the lead in the film.

reply

I think the case would be lost without him saying that.


I was about to tease you, and say that's the point of the movie, but based on some people's responses here, it looks like a few ppl missed it too.

But yeah, avoided this film for the longest time until I realized what Grisham was going for here. It's not about guilt or culpability. It's about the jury.

reply