MovieChat Forums > Sailor Moon (1995) Discussion > I feel bad for Americans...

I feel bad for Americans...


The SM anime you grew up watching is nothing like the real Sailor Moon Japanese series. I'm glad we had original language version here in Poland - you could feel the spirit of the 90's Japan and also enjoy the AMAZING voice-acting of Japanese seiyuus like Kotono Mitsuishi. What they did with English/American dubbing, is just a silly parody, so... watch the real thing ASAP.

reply

The American dub of Sailor Moon isn't nearly as bad as the travesty that was the American version of Card Captor Sakura. They cut the first 8 episodes, changed some of the main story points, and had terrible voice acting.

👷👳
Bob the Builder and Hadji walk into a bar...

reply

The Viz English dub is actually well done IMO,way better than the Dic Dub.
Its not impossible to make a good English Dub,The Dragon Ball Z Kai dub is actually good as well. I will some English Dubs sounded terrible back in the day,but they are getting better at making them
If only Proper Pokemon and YugiOh Dubs can be made I would very happy





I'm gonna show you something beautiful everyone screaming for mercy

reply

The only DBZ dub that ever sounded any good to me was the first run of Ocean episodes. That was akin to the Sailor Moon dub where the changes were vast and it sort of became its own unique thing. I agree the Kai dub is an improvement over Funimation's past dubs but it still isn't very good IMHO. The voices sound too goofy to me.

Dubs definitely can be just as good as the Japanese version sometimes, though. Gundam Wing would be my first example. I prefer the Japanese version but the voice actors they cast for the dub sound astoundingly similar to their counterparts in the original. Even the vocal inflections between the two versions were often the same. Also noteworthy since it was one of the first Toonami shows where the DVDs were uncut and dual-language, back in the days when most anime was still edited to Hell like DBZ and Sailor Moon.

But I digress.... There are plenty of good dubs out there. In the end, which version someone prefers is, of course, up to them.

---
Pride is not the opposite of shame, but its source. True humility is the antidote to shame.

reply

The only DBZ dub that ever sounded any good to me was the first run of Ocean episodes. That was akin to the Sailor Moon dub where the changes were vast and it sort of became its own unique thing. I agree the Kai dub is an improvement over Funimation's past dubs but it still isn't very good IMHO. The voices sound too goofy to me.


The Kai Dub is great and a huge improvement over any DBZ Dub in the Past.You can't be serious about the Ocean Dub being the good DBZ Dub that honor belongs to the Kai Dub. The Ocean Dub had terrible music and voice acting,almost none of the actors voices went with the characters maybe except for possibly the guy that played the Older Gohan,but the funimation Older Gohan is better. People also for whatever reason love Goku's Voice Actors from that Dub,but both sounded too high pitched he is suppose to be a man Child Sean Schemmel captures that perfectly. Almost all the voice actors from the Funimation Dub were perfect for the roles but they working with terrible scripts and directions,but they have better material in the Kai Dub.

Sailor Moon's Dic Dub had a similar problem that DBZ had with the Ocean Dub the Music was not that good and neither was the voice acting,although I think a few of the voice actors were actually decent in their roles despite the terrible material,but several of them were terrible like all the Sailor Moon voice actresses sounded too old to voice a Schoolgirl,Luna sounded like an Old British Woman and Sailor Moon's Friend had a Jersey Accent,but the Viz voice actors are way better in the roles and Viz actually keeps the characters names intact.






Dubs definitely can be just as good as the Japanese version sometimes, though.


Yeah they could be just as great as the Japanese Version,but How can you say that and not like the DBZ KAi Dub?

Gundam Wing would be my first example


Thats one example of a good early English Dub


But I digress.... There are plenty of good dubs out there. In the end, which version someone prefers is, of course, up to them.



I never said there were not any good dubs,I was saying some of them sounded terrible back then especially the early Sailor Moon and DBZ Dubs. Yes it is up to the people which they prefer but the critizim those early dubs get is very fair and understandable


I'm gonna show you something beautiful everyone screaming for mercy

reply

I'm going to have to respectfully think you're utterly insane. A few are great, but most of Funimation's DBZ voice cast sounds like they're perpetually constipated and sadly they still do even in the latest version. Most of them don't sound like they're taking the character seriously, like "err grr rawr" they sound more like they're voicing Smokey The Bear than a character in a straight-faced show. Which is a shame because a lot of them are actually fantastic voice actors, clearly the direction they're being given is "sound more cartoonish, take this less seriously." And young Gohan in Kai is just hilarious... like, wow no attempt at all to sound like a male. I've dated 20-something year old girls who sound more like a young male character than Kai's Gohan.

The Ocean Dub had terrible music


O_______O

Shuki Levy is one the greatest composers in the history of kid's television. That Inspector Gadget theme is one of the most iconic and catchiest TV themes of all-time, I haven't seen an episode of that show in 20 years and I can still remember the song like it was yesterday. His score for DBZ was atmospheric, tense, and beautiful, exactly what they needed for the show. Granted it's no match for the impeccably gorgeous orchestral instrumentations from the Japanese version, but boy golly did all the techno and hard rawk crap they used in between Ocean and the original sound terrible. It was bad music not just for the atmosphere of the show, it was also just plain bad music.

The thing that's great about the Ocean dub and the DiC dub is that they go their own way and become their own unique show. Ocean's DBZ and DiC's Sailor Moon would easily stand up to any other American cartoon from that time period, and that's what they produced as: American cartoons. I'm glad that people who don't like subs get to see a closer version to the original of Sailor Moon and DBZ now, but compared to the original these new versions still suck balls. Whereas with Ocean and DiC at least you have the excuse that it's something different, it's not trying to compete with the markedly superior original version.

I never said there were not any good dubs


I know, I was agreeing with you, saying 'yeah, there are some good ones and some bad ones.'

I definitely agree that Kai is Funimation's best attempt yet. But it's still not on par with what the Ocean Group did at the beginning. Sure they cut out a lot of stuff, but, heh, so did Kai. A lot of that crap needed to be cut out to make the show stronger and tighter.

---
Pride is not the opposite of shame, but its source. True humility is the antidote to shame.

reply

I'm going to have to respectfully think you're utterly insane


I am perfectly sane and could see The Ocean and Dic Dubs for what they really are


A few are great, but most of Funimation's DBZ voice cast sounds like they're perpetually constipated and sadly they still do even in the latest version.


Most are perfect for their roles and sound a lot better in Kai



on's DBZ voice cast sounds like they're perpetually constipated and sadly they still do even in the latest version. Most of them don't sound like they're taking the character seriously, like "err grr rawr" they sound more like they're voicing Smokey The Bear than a character in a straight-faced show. Which is a shame because a lot of them are actually fantastic voice actors, clearly the direction they're being given is "sound more cartoonish, take this less seriously."



You say the cast does not sound like they are taking the character seriously thats how the Ocean Dub sounded and the direction the cast has given in Kai is great and shows


And young Gohan in Kai is just hilarious... like, wow no attempt at all to sound like a male. I've dated 20-something year old girls who sound more like a young male character than Kai's Gohan.


Thats the best Young Gohan in an English Dub we have seen the voice is great




Shuki Levy is one the greatest composers


His music works for Power Rangers and Inspector Gadget but it was god awful for DBZ



The thing that's great about the Ocean dub and the DiC dub is that they go their own way and become their own unique show.


I got ask whats unique about those dubs? they have terrible voice acting,terrible music and the content was heavily edited

I'm glad that people who don't like subs get to see a closer version to the original of Sailor Moon and DBZ now,


Thats how it should have been made from the Start,it took 15 years for people to finally get serious about the shows and give them proper Dubs. Its funny how you say the current dubs suck Balls,but you for whatever reason love those old dubs. What the Hell

but compared to the original these new versions still suck balls.


How the hell can you say the current Dubs for Sailor Moon and DBZ suck Balls and are not as good as the original,when they actually are alot closer to the original and enjoy those early dubs that are nothing like the original? 

I definitely agree that Kai is Funimation's best attempt yet. But it's still not on par with what the Ocean Group did at the beginning. Sure they cut out a lot of stuff, but, heh, so did Kai. A lot of that crap needed to be cut out to make the show stronger and tighter.



Its not just Funimation's best Attempt its the best Attempt at a DBZ English Dub period,yeah the Ocean Dub just butchered it thats what they did. What did Kai Cut out?


I'm gonna show you something beautiful everyone screaming for mercy

reply

You say the cast does not sound like they are taking the character seriously thats how the Ocean Dub sounded


In other words the "I'm not a poopy-head, you're a poopy-head!" tactic. You literally just took what I said and repeated it in reverse.

The Ocean voice actors were a group of established North American cartoon voice actors and they voiced it like a serious American cartoon. Funimation's voice actors make it sound exactly like a parody, they sound like they could be working on DBZ Abridged instead.

Thats the best Young Gohan in an English Dub we have seen the voice is great


Have to disagree with you, the previous Gohan actually wasn't so bad. Especially compared to the new Kai one that sounds like a girl.

I got ask whats unique about those dubs?


You mean other than the fact that the Ocean Group slipped a lot of the filler out of Z almost 15 years before Kai? That was pretty unique. What's unique about those dubs is that they have their own style, independent from that of the original. It's crap compared to the original, but at least it stands on its own.

How the hell can you say the current Dubs for Sailor Moon and DBZ suck Balls and are not as good as the original,when they actually are alot closer to the original and enjoy those early dubs that are nothing like the original?


That's actually exactly my point. The reason that I like the DIC and Ocean dubs is because they stand on their own, they are nothing like the original.

I love the original DBZ/Kai and the original Sailor Moon. Watching a dubbed version that is the same except it has terrible voices, well that makes me want to bash my head into the wall!

But watching a version that is so completely different that it's not even remotely the same, well I don't care about the changes then. Because it's like it's a completely different show. The same way that the film Starcrash was a blatant Italian ripoff of Star Wars, the Ocean & Dic dubs could almost have been blatant North American ripoffs of DBZ and Sailor Moon. They're so far removed from the originals that I can appreciate them as if they're entirely different shows -- poor, derivative shows, but charming in their own way.

What did Kai Cut out?


Almost half the series. That was literally the entire point of Kai! Although sadly it got progressively less as time went on. Cell and Buu could have used a LOT more editing whereas the Saiyan arc could have used juuust a little less. Namek/Freeza was pretty much the perfect amount of editing except for constantly cutting to Goku in a tank blowing bubbles. Completely pointless and it kills the tension if they constantly remind you "Hey, don't worry, Goku's gonna be super powerful when he gets out!" But I digress.

My point is that, while their motives were a lot more sinister, the Ocean Group effectively did the same thing as Kai did: cut out some of the filler from Z.

Its not just Funimation's best Attempt its the best Attempt at a DBZ English Dub period


Weeeeee're. gonna just have to agree to disagree here. Thanks for the chat, though. It's always fun to discuss DBZ.


---
Pride is not the opposite of shame, but its source. True humility is the antidote to shame.

reply

In other words the "I'm not a poopy-head, you're a poopy-head!" tactic. You literally just took what I said and repeated it in reverse.

The Ocean voice actors were a group of established North American cartoon voice actors and they voiced it like a serious American cartoon. Funimation's voice actors make it sound exactly like a parody, they sound like they could be working on DBZ Abridged instead.


There is no tactic here I felt the Ocean Dub actors were not taking anything seriously when dubbing DBZ,Yeah some of them are great voice actors but almost all of them were terrible for the roles other than maybe the guy that voiced the Older Gohan,but Kyle Hebert from Fuimation is the best Older Gohan




Have to disagree with you, the previous Gohan actually wasn't so bad. Especially compared to the new Kai one that sounds like a girl.


colleen clinkenbeard sounds like a boy when voicing Gohan and she also voices Android 18 and sounds like a Teenage Girl,the previous actress sounded too cougarish,thats some talent right there



You mean other than the fact that the Ocean Group slipped a lot of the filler out of Z almost 15 years before Kai? That was pretty unique. What's unique about those dubs is that they have their own style, independent from that of the original. It's crap compared to the original, but at least it stands on its own.


They skipped Filler so what it still sucked and sounded terrible. You are really confusing me, you seem to acknowledge that Dub is crap but still think its unique.




I love the original DBZ/Kai and the original Sailor Moon. Watching a dubbed version that is the same except it has terrible voices, well that makes me want to bash my head into the wall!


Another thing that confuses me people claim to love the original versions of DBZ and Sailor Moon,but prefer those older dubs over the newer Dubs which are more closer to the original



But watching a version that is so completely different that it's not even remotely the same, well I don't care about the changes then. Because it's like it's a completely different show. The same way that the film Starcrash was a blatant Italian ripoff of Star Wars, the Ocean & Dic dubs could almost have been blatant North American ripoffs of DBZ and Sailor Moon. They're so far removed from the originals that I can appreciate them as if they're entirely different shows -- poor, derivative shows, but charming in their own way.

Ocean Group and Dic were not trying to make new shows that are exactly like DBZ and Sailor Moon,they were just dubbing those series and were not trying to make those Unique they were still trying to be DBZ and Sailor Moon




Almost half the series. That was literally the entire point of Kai!
.


Yeah that was the point of Kai



My point is that, while their motives were a lot more sinister, the Ocean Group effectively did the same thing as Kai did: cut out some of the filler from Z.


One difference though Ocean Group made a terrible dub



Weeeeee're. gonna just have to agree to disagree here. Thanks for the chat, though. It's always fun to discuss DBZ.


If you are done responding take care


I'm gonna show you something beautiful everyone screaming for mercy

reply

I still like our dub of Sailor Moon even if it wasn't a faithful dub.

"I hate my life."-Ed Bighead

reply

They definitely should not have edited out Japanese culture and Neptune/Uranus's romance, although the only openly gay or bi male characters being villains was weird in the original, but maybe written with some good intentions, but the old dub did have some charm, and I still like it. I just pretend Uranus and Neptune are disguised as cousins. I always saw them as a couple.

reply