funniest ending ever
does anyone else agree that, the borther in the end yelling was overly dramatic and te funniest thing ever.
does anyone else agree that, the borther in the end yelling was overly dramatic and te funniest thing ever.
The only way you could find this ending "funny" is if you don't have a clue about what's happening.
Peter (Robert Sean Leonard) is being taken away in a truck to a concentration camp. Hilarious! His younger brother comes running up as the truck pulls away, and he knows exactly what's happening, because it happened a lot back then.
He is aware that he will never see his brother again and that he's going to die. By shouting "Swing Heil!" at the top of his lungs in front of all the Nazis who just raided the club, he is risking his own life as well.
Yeah, that's the funniest ending ever.
It was funny. It was just so awkward how dramatic it was. He yells like 5 times and each time it's just worse and worse. Cheesy.
shareEven when I understood what was happening it was funny what the younger brother was doing because it was unbelievably corny beyond redemption. That yelling and crying was just tooooo much! It ruined the drama for so many viewers. They should have had him maybe just crying and calling out his name, not yelling out 'Swing Heil' and thrusting the umbrella. It was just too much!
shareWe watched it in my AP Euro class this week (we finished the AP test last Friday, so we had nothing left to do for the last two and a half weeks of school). During this part, it wasn't the fact that it was way over dramatic or all that that got to me, it was the way he said it. "ZVEENG HAY-ELL! ZVEENG HAY-ELL!" I was the only person, it seemed, that was fighting laughter, but I was looking around and everyone else was stoic (probably because they realized what was happening; I did too, but God, Willi made that scene so funny...which I know he shouldn't have).
-----
Sometimes I believe in six impossible things before breakfast.
You are my way Jesus. †
A lot of the awkwardness of that scene was because it was an American actor trying to speak German. If you see the German dubbed version the scene is much less silly...
"IMdB; where 14 year olds can act like jaded 40 year old critics...'
It was so overdramatic, i felt so out of place because nobody else was laughing but me. Good thing it was dark.
shareThe whole movie is good up until that point. And then the younger brother ruins the ending with his ridiculous cheesy delivery of Swing Heil. How that was left in the movie I'll never know.
shareIt really is hard to believe that NOBODY said to the director or producer ... let's think about this ending? I mean they just shot themselves in the foot.
shareYeah it definitely had the opposite effect of what was intended!
It's sad when a scene is so unintentially funny!
I thought Willie was going to grab the umbrella and hit Thomas with it.
shareI watched it for the first time in years, knew it was coming, and managed not to laugh.
The alternate ending was better.
what is the alternate ending?
shareThis whole thread reminds me of a news story I saw on television years ago about some people laughing at the executions in "Schindler's List".
The implications of people laughing at these scenes make me very nervous.
Come on!!! It was a really silly way to end the film ... no matter what the implications. Change the ending and this films jumps from a 6.7 to a 7.2. It was just that bad!
shareto a NAzi lover maybe
share[deleted]
Funny? It is one of the most tragic endings of any movie I've ever seen.
You do understand that his older brother was being hauled off to jail, perhaps to a labor camp? Though at the time of the story, labor/execution camps weren't well-known, people understood the Gestapo well enough to know that anyone hauled off by them was often not seen by their families or friends again.
The little brother's cry was a loud pledge that he would take up the cause
of his brother.
The Swing Kids were not simply guilty of violating Nazi laws. They were a
clear indication that, despite the worst that evil men can do, some will
rise against the evil and endeavor to make good come out of the confrontations with evil.
The Swing Kids were the German spiritual ancestors of the unknown man who stood in front of the People's Liberation Army tank in Tiananmen Square during the freedom protests of 1989, daring the driver to run him down. The protestors of Tiananmen Square wanted only what the Swing Kids wanted--freedom and the right to be themselves. Both in Germany and China, the government, instead of allowing people freedom, they dealt them death.
Swing Kids is a movie of warning as well as the clash of good and evil.