Why Did Chancellor Gorkon Say...


You've not experienced Shakespeare until you've read him in the original Klingon?

Is he implying that Shakespeare is a Klingon?

reply

No, he’s implying that the Klingon language allows for nuances which are not present in the English language, and as such, when Shakespeare’s works are translated to Klingon, they have more depth, more room to breath, thus allowing for a more enjoyable reading experience.

reply

Then how do you explain the use of the word 'original'?

reply

Original Klingon implies that there have been deviations, or possibly evolutions in the Klingon language, similar to the English language, old English, middle English and modern English.
And it doesn’t make sense that Shakespeare would be Klingon given that his stories are made up of human characters, Henry the VIII for example.

reply

There's no reason to believe the Klingon versions didn't simply transplant their own historic Kings and leaders in place of Lear, Henry etc

reply

I just think it’s a stretch is all, just my opinion. It would be a great question to ask one of the OG cast members/crew though!

reply

because of WS greatness, he is "claiming him" for the klingon race

he knows it is not really true

reply

And I also thought it was a nice touch, in showing the Klingons and crew of the Enterprise are not as different as they think they are, they both enjoy Shakespeare as well as Romulan wine, but both are a bit too pig headed to see the light at the end of tunnel.

reply

well said

reply

Well Spock implied he was a direct descendant of Sherlock Holmes so why not? :-)

I expect that the real reason was a reference to how Nikita Khrushchev claimed to Vice President Richard Nixon that Russians did everything better than Americans when they met.

reply

I assume he's implying that it's originally Klingon. But is that ridiculous? Yes and no...

I think it's a bit of a Cold War joke. Chekhov got some similar lines on the original show, about how such-and-such a thing was Russian when it wasn't. He claimed the Cheshire Cat was from Minsk, for example, and that scotch whisky was invented in Leningrad. Here's a video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IC6W8J0j8Co&t=125s

This thread talks about it a bit more: USSR brainwashing was at play to convince their people that Russia was the greatest country in the world. https://scifi.stackexchange.com/questions/17707/does-chekov-believe-his-claims

Because of the Cold War parallels present throughout Star Trek, but particularly with The Undiscovered Country, this line about Shakespeare being Klingon is, in my opinion, meant to be an echo, extension, or reference to the USSR thing.

Of course, even without brainwashing, countries tend to develop an overinflated sense of self-worth. Ask people about which lineage is responsible for the telephone or heavier-than-air flight, for instance, and you'll get an interesting stew of answers.

In short, Gorkon probably was claiming Shakespeare for his people, and Star Trek VI was setting up a parallel to the real world in an amusing, if over-exaggerated, way.

reply

This was my understanding, it's a parallel of the US/Soviet one-upmanship

Claiming your enemies greatest people as your own.

The question is how literal is he being. I would say very.

reply

Oh, yes, for me, too: Gorkon meant that Shakespeare's works were originally Klingon works, later translated into English. Now, it's ambiguous as to what exactly he thinks went down in London in the 1590s - if he's even given it any thought - but as far as I can tell, he means what he says word-for-word.

reply