A definitive list of 'movies like this'
A Pure Formality
An Occurrence at Owl Creek Bridge
Angel Heart
Brazil
Carnival of Souls
Dead End
Deathdream
Donnie Darko
Enter the Void
Johnny Got His Gun
Open Your Eyes
Passengers
Room 6
Silent Hill
Soul Survivors
Stay
Sublime
The I Inside
The Jacket
The Others
The Seventh Seal
The Sixth Sense
Vanilla Sky