MovieChat Forums > Back to the Future Part II (1989) Discussion > The whole premise to Back to the Future ...

The whole premise to Back to the Future 2 doesn't make any sense.


https://www.reddit.com/r/movies/comments/9rv218/the_whole_premise_to_back_to_the_future_2_doesnt/

When Doc comes back to the present to tell Marty that his son will be in trouble in the future, that is all that is necessary to prevent that from happening. 1985 Marty doesn't need to move forward in time to prevent the future event from happening, he can organically prevent it from happening when 2015 arrives. By going forward in time, he creates the unnecessary mess by clueing in future Biff.

Too bad. It was the best movie of the franchise as a kid.

reply

One could argue that the further back in time one tries to fix a problem, the more likely "externalities" or unintended/undesired results will ripple or "butterfly" out from the intended change.

From that perspective, a quick jaunt into the future to change one small interaction between Marty Jr and Griff is the least threatening to the space/time continuum.

Trying to change it 30 years earlier is just too risky!

However, then one must realize 30 years earlier is exactly what happened in Movie 1, but none of that was exactly intentional, so perhaps that strengthens this argument.

But then one must also consider Movie 3. If 30 years is risky, what of 100 years?

Back to Movie 2- if 30 years can cause so many rippled externalities, then bringing 2 people forward 30 years- AND THEN RETURNING THEM TO THE PRESENT is probably a bad idea.

But the rest of Movie 2 and all of Movie 3 only prove that to be the case! So maybe one was right to argue all along.

reply

despite being raised by the charismatic, energetic, brave never back down leader Marty Mcfly sr it seems jr was destined to be a awkward, dweeby pussy follower.

It seems no amount of raising would have changed jr's nature. And as the film says it sets off a chain reaction that destroys the family. Even if he did warn his son about this specific event and try and raise him better and he backed down. its likely his son would have gotten drawn into another one of Biffs plans.

this way his bad influence goes to jail, Marty doesn't give into being goaded ect.

reply