MovieChat Forums > The Natural (1984) Discussion > Greatest Real MLB Moments?

Greatest Real MLB Moments?


Well, being a massive Dodgers fan, i'd have to go with Kirk Gibson's game winner, but what would you say?

Ash: Gimme some sugar, baby.

reply

[deleted]

Mazerowski's walk off home run to beat the Yankees in game 7 of the '60 World Series. Larson's perfect game in the '56 series. Amoros making that great catch in left field to preserve Podres's game 7 victory over the Yankees in '55, as the Dodgers finally win the Series. Thompson's "shot heard round the world" in the '51 playoff against the Dodgers. Most painful great moment for this Indians fan, Mays making "The Catch" in game 1 of the '54 series, turning all the momentum in the Giants' favor.

reply

Mike Schmidt hitting a two run home run in the 11th inning to clinch the pennant in Montreal in 1980. Montreal was the team there were tied with. If you remember the stadium the Expos played in, you'll remember it was huge (in fact a few years later the fences had to be moved IN). If you are a Phillies fan than you know the significance of this homer. After years of failure in the playoffs, as a team and Schmidt coming up small in those games, this was their and his time. Schmidt buried it and the rest is history.

Also, Gibby's homer was second for me. (sorry I'm from Philly..lol)

Nolan Ryan's pitching his last two no hitters (without the juice Clemmens!!!!)

Kirby Puckett doing EVERYTHING to win his second World Series.

and Ken Griffey Sr and Jr hitting back to back homers.

reply

1. Brad Ausmus hits a tying homerun to send them into extra innnings in the NLCS vs. the Cards in 2005..and then Burke hit the game winning homer in the 18th inning..the 'Stros eventually went to the Series..I have the framed newspaper from the morning after they clinched "HOUSTON, WE HAVE A PENNANT" it reads..it was very uplifting..cause we were still getting used to life after Hurricane Rita tore through southeast Texas.

2. 2007 season Red Sox rookie Clay Bucholtz throws a no hitter..I played against him in high school and he shredded us to pieces..it's nice seeing I wasn't the only one having trouble hitting off that kid.

3. Anytime Adam Dunn homers..I was too young to play against him, but my brother did..his school was in our district when he was in high school.

I see the stars...I hear the rolling thunder..Thy power, throughout the universe displayed.

reply

Kirby Puckett doing EVERYTHING to win his second World Series.
Oh man, ya. The 1991 World Series might've been the best ever.

reply

1. Kirk Gibson HR- Game One 1988 WS

2. Bobby Thompson,1951playoff vs Dodgers

3.Bob Gibson,1968 WS Game One masterpiece

4.Reggie Jackson HR in 1971 All-Star game. The longest ever?

5.Bernie Carbo's 3 run homer in Game 6, 1975 WS. Wouldn't have Fisk's without it.

6.Dave Henderson's 9th inning homer, Game 5 1986 ALCS.

reply

Hank Aaron's Home Run off the Cardinals' Billy Muffet in 11th inning on September 23, 1957 to clich NL pennant for Milwaukee Braves. I saw an interview in which Aaron said that was his most memorable homer.

Foreman's not as easy as Cameron. But, of course, who is? -- Dr. House

reply

[deleted]

Lou Gehrigs farewell speach.
Jack Morris 10 inning shutout.
Pucketts catch.
Pucketts walkoff.
Don Larsens perfect game.
Ruths called shot.

Just to name a few of my favorites.

reply

My favorite is Kirby Puckett hitting the walk-off home run in Game 6 in the '91 series. "We'll see you tomorrow night!"

reply

Gibson's home run tops them all. It was only game 1, but of course, we all know the story. It was magical. And it was aided by some of the most elegant commentating of Vin Scully's career. Simply priceless.


Aside from that, you just can't beat the series-winning home runs of Carter and Mazeroski. Bobby Thomson is their equal because of the massive comeback of the Giants that season.

Everything else pales in comparison, in my opinion.

I'm surprised so many people have overlooked Carter's home run, but I suppose this sort of thing is subjective.

reply

Watching Jonathan Sanchez’s no hitter for the Giants up in Frisco a couple weeks ago. Intense: the crowd, the game, the fog, the night sky. Everything.

One catch by the CF in the top of the 9th was akin to the catch in this movie where the guy runs through the wall. But the Giant didn’t, thankfully. And he didn't die, either. Always a good thing.

What was neat was Sanchez’s dad had never seen him pitch in the MLB in person before the game he pitched the no hitter.

Also: I had this book in my overcoat pocket at the time.

reply

Joe Carter's World Series-winning homerun for the Toronto Blue Jays. I can't think of a greater baseball moment in the past 20 years.

reply

I'm only 22 so I wasn't able to see Gibson's homer live, but as far as I can tell that's the greatest moment in MLB history.

As a Cleveland fan, two very special ones for me are Sandy Alomar's game-winning HR in the '97 All Star Game (which was in Cleveland) and his game winning HR off Mariano Rivera in Game 4 of the ALDS that same year. The Tribe went all the way to game 7--and inning 9- of the Series that year only to lose it. But that's just baseball for you. What a fantastic year.

Approximate number of movies I've seen in the theater: 83.

reply

haha wow just looked through the rest of this nest and saw that i already wrote about these moments years ago.

Hope everyone is excited for a new season--I just watched this movie to get in the mood. Never seen it all the way through before tonight. Great flick!!

Approximate number of movies I've seen in the theater: 83.

reply

3. Greg Maddux throwing a complete game shutout with just 78 pitches. Less than 9 pitches per inning.

2. Dante Bichette opening Coors Field with a walk-off 14th inning homer.

1. Nolan Ryan putting Robin Venturan in a headlock and pummeling him for charging the mound. If you're going to charge the mound, you'd better be able to take out the pitcher, especially if he's in his mid-40s.

_______
"She flattened a Dear John with a John Deere." - Douglas Wambaugh

reply

"...and the 0-1 pitch on the way to Edgar Martinez...swung on and lined down the left field line for a base hit! Here comes Joey! Here is Junior to third base..they're gonna wave him in! The throw to the plate will be....LATE! THE MARINERS ARE GOING TO PLAY FOR THE AMERICAN LEAGUE CHAMPIONSHIP! I DON'T BELIEVE IT! IT JUST CONTINUES!"


I can't believe this thread is going on 7 years old and I'm the first one to mention The Double. Game 5 of 95 ALDS is ranked by the MLB itself as the 15th greatest game ever played.


Is this anyway to treat the team that saved baseball? (i might be overdoing it here)


Refuse To Lose

reply

I was there, down that left field line. Probably the best sports moment I've ever witnessed. That late run to the playoffs by the Mariners arguably saved baseball in Seattle no doubt. Well, the politicians made sure it saved baseball because a public vote around that time came up short for providing public funds for building the swanky new Safeco Field! But as we know it did get built despite a non-majority of voters supporting it. Crazy world.

Game 6 of the 2011 World Series has clearly got to be one of the greatest real MLB moments- the entire series was amazing.

reply

i agree with most of these but nobody had chris chamblisses playoff series walk off homer to put the yankees in the world series in 76 after a 12 year absence.

reply

Game 7 of the 2001 World Series and Game 6 of the 2011 World Series come to mind.



http://most-underrated-movies.blogspot.com/

reply

As a Giants fan, Brian Wilson striking out Nelson Cruz to end the 2010 World Series. From the 2002 Game 6 nightmare, I was convinced, after Edgar Renteria put the Giants up 3-0 with his homer, that the roof was going to cave in again. After Wilson ended it, I started laughing with relief. Other highlights from that postseason: the Renteria homer itself, the rally to win NLDS Game 3 after being down to their last strike, Cody Ross breaking up Derek Lowe's no-hitter with a homer in NLDS Game 4, Juan Uribe's walk-off sacrifice fly in NLCS Game 4, Uribe's go-ahead homer in NLCS Game 6, and Wilson inducing a line-out double play to kill a Phillies rally in the eighth inning of NLCS Game 6.

Also, other title-drought-enders, such as the Red Sox winning in '04 and the White Sox in '05. Did you notice that teams that have been through long periods without a WS title tend to win the WS only in blowouts (Red Sox, White Sox, Giants) or by beating similarly cursed teams (Braves over Indians, Angels over Giants)?

reply

Since my lost post was 6 years ago, here are some new ones from me:

2007-Phillies, seemingly out of it, go on a September tear to overtake the Mets on the last day of the season. Of course we subsequently get swept by the Rockies.

2008-Game 2 NLDS, Brett Myers has long at bat against CC Sabbathia in which he ended up walking. Then Shane Victorino hitting the grand slam to break the game open.

2008-Game 4 NLCS Phils down 5-3 in the 8th. Victorino hits a liner over the left field wall to tie the game. Then Matt Stairs hits a bomb to left off of Broxton(beginning Broxton's string of futility against the Phillies). This pretty much wraps up the series(Phils won 5-1 in game 5).

2008-Game 4 World Series-Joe Blanton hits first world series homerun by a pitcher since 1974.

2009-Game 1 NLDS, Roy Halladay throwing only the 2nd no-hitter in in post season history, this after pitching a perfect game earlier in the season.

reply

Point of playing the season is to win the World Series so my top 5 include:

1. Bill Mazeroski's Series walkoff HR - game was tied 9-9, series was tied 3-3

2. Joe Carter's Series walkoff HR - they won the Series 4-2


Incredible considering the circumstance and the culmination of one of the greatest comebacks ever:

3. Bobby Thompson's "Shot Heard Round the World"


Future Implications on the game:

4. Jackie Robinson plays - take that Ty Cobb!


Momentous Career Achievements:

5. Hank Aaron's 715 - overcame death threats and tons of other obstacles to reach it

reply

chris davis pitching a scoreless 16th inning @ the red sox last year for the o's.




Season's Greetings

reply