This film is insulting


As someone who is from Uruguay I must say this film is completely disrespectful. I was watching this film and enjoying it up until the part where they show Szell's hideout in Uruguay. I was like: 'WHAT?', because apparently we have jungles here and I didn't even notice. I know most of you people don't even know where Uruguay is and don't care about this, but I ask you: if they depicted your country in a film in a completely wrong way, wouldn't you be pissed off?. Filmmakers should do a little research if they are going to put something in a film they know nothing about.
Luckily this mistake is shown in the goofs section for this movie:
"Errors in geography: Dr. Szell is supposed to be living in Uruguay before going to New York. We see shots of what is supposed to be Uruguay which show people traveling in canoes through the jungle, but in Uruguay there is no jungle."

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

EDIT (7 years later): Hey guys, good news: I'm over it now.
Calling the film insulting was too much, I admit; I do remember being pretty irritated when I wrote the message above. Of course, that it inaccurately depicts Uruguay's geography is undeniable.
I would delete this post, but hey, many of your responses are pretty funny!


It's not the years, honey, it's the mileage.
Indiana Jones, "Raiders of the Lost Ark"

reply

I happen to be watching MM at the moment and I must admit that I didn't think it had a large bearing on the film, but I can understand why somebody might be sensitive about a portrayal of their home. In the UK we suffer quite a bit from Hollywood rewriting history, especially about things we did in World War II which are then portrayed as US operations, but I'd never really considered geographical inaccuracies. The UK's (in)famous costume dramas are nearly all filmed in Central Europe and nobody bats an eyelid.

It is far far worse if the inhabitants of your country or of your race or religion are portrayed as something they are not - unless it is for comedy :-) ... and even then be careful.

I am sure all the director cared about, with MM, was making a great film.

reply

[deleted]

Go to the website called tvtropes.org. Search for a page called "The Mountains of Illinois." You'll find that these blunders are common in movies.

I disagree with what you are saying, but I will defend to your death your right to say it;-)

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

I am an American from Boston and I know where Uruguay is (I had a very nice friend from Bolivia when I was in college). I think most Americans, when we think of South America, we think of Columbia (from that movie "Romancing the Stone") where there are a lot of jungle scenes. It's just a scene in a movie, not meant to be offensive or insulting. Lighten up!!!

reply

Certain nations in S.America willingly harboured known nazi war criminals via the ODESSA escape route in connivance with the Vatican. Mossad and Wiesenthal unravelled it. Get over it.

reply

Hate to say it, but I do not give a rats wazoo about Argentina and Uruguay, NAZI harboring scum-holes of countries they are.

sorry the films geography (depicting jungles) offends the OP. The country's harboring of NAZI war Criminals offends me!

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

[deleted]