Who killed the assassins?


Michael cleverly deducts that there's someone inside the family orchestrating with outside forces and we later learn that it was Fredo, but we know Fredo is not handy with a gun by any measure. So who else was embedded in the Corleone family to arrange the hit and then take out the assassins?

Some previous threads pointed to Rocco, but that doesn't make sense because why would Michael keep Rocco around through most of the movie after being a collaborator on that level?

reply

I don't know that it was someone inside. It may have been a double-cross by someone working with the hit team and who was supposed to transport them out of the area, but executed them instead.

reply

That would be the only logical explanation, but the reason it irks me is because in earlier posts back in the Imdb days there was a theory floating around that Rocco was part of the betrayal but Michael didn't want to reveal that he knew this until he knew he had Hyman Roth on the ropes and then he has Rocco go on a suicide mission to rectify his betrayal.

reply

best explanation I've heard - sort of like the bank robbery at the beginning of Dark Knight.
3 guys on the hit squad, one of them kills the other 2 and either gets out (using inside-info of the compound from Fredo) or does a good job of hiding (or maybe Fredo hides him?!) until it's safe to leave - once Michael's men find the 2 bodies, they'll stop looking for anyone else.
Having rewatched last night, you don't hear any further gunshots after the attempt, and the dead men look like they've had their throats cut. So definitely not Fredo.
One interesting thing I hadn't noticed before though was Fredo's wife (Deanna?) is the one who "discovers" the bodies and starts screaming "Mike, they're dead. They're right outside my room". What if this was a diversion while Fredo helped hide or smuggle out the 3rd assassin?

That said, when Michael's talking to Tom and says that they wont be found alive and that there's been a betrayal, Tom starts saying "you don't think Rocco or Neri...?" and Michael says that they're only connected to him by business so why not.
So he clearly suspected anyone but Tom (and ironically Fredo and Connie by extension!).

reply

Wasn't it Fredo?

reply

No, and Fredo is too incompetent to carry out a double-cross hit on the assassins. He wasn't even good at keeping a low profile in Cuba when he was transporting Michael's money in that suitcase as well as keeping his betrayal a secret when they went out later to party with the Senator.

reply

Agreed, no way Fredo could handle something like that.

reply

Roth had a third-party at the scene who killed the assassins afterwards

reply

The assassins killed themselves.

reply

How do the assassin's go about slitting their own throats?

reply

Hdyk their throats were slit

reply

You take knife…

reply