MovieChat Forums > High Plains Drifter (1973) Discussion > Clint's fondness for depicting violence ...

Clint's fondness for depicting violence against women


A lot of his movies feature scenes that depict violence against women.


High Plains Drifter (Sorry--even if the woman was not blameless, it was still rape)

The Outlaw Josey Wales (the attempted rape of Sondra Locke)

Sudden Impact (Sondra Locke raped)

The Gauntlet (Sondra Locke again threatened with rape--I think--might be
wrong about this one

Pale Rider (attempted rape of Megan)

Tightrope (serial killer raping and murdering women)

Unforgiven (cutting of the prostitute at the beginning)

Absolute Power (Christy Sullivan is beaten, choked, shot)

Million Dollar Baby (women fighting in the boxing ring)

Mystic River (murder of Katie)


I'm sure there are others I am forgetting.

reply

First off, the movies you've listed are not all "his" movies; actors hire on to play a part in a film that was written by someone else.

reply

Welcome to the real world

reply

Welcome to the real world

reply

Obviously OP doesn't like his political views so came up with this. About every person on the left, such as Alec Baldwin, has portrayed terrible people.

reply

Stick to Disney movies then....

reply

Yes, because nothing horrific ever happens in Disney movies.

reply

Actually, I've literally never seen anything chocking in a Disney movie. They are mostly meant for a large audience, and target especially a young audience. But if you can prove me wrong?

reply

High Plains Drifter (Sorry--even if the woman was not blameless, it was still rape)
But it would have been OK if the woman had been bull-whipped to death by three men the way the sheriff was?

It amazes me how a woman (who was possibly the town whore) being violated is somehow more offensive than an innocent man getting slaughtered.

reply

She wasn't the town whore and even if she was it doesn't give him the right to rape her. He can get his revenge on the men but leave
Innocent women alone.

reply

Go home, little girl, go home.

reply

I'm a guy not a girl. What made you think I was female? I like Casey Anthony remember?

reply

If you think she was "innocent' then you did not understand the movie at all.

reply

Exactly. The whole town was complicit in the murder of Jim Duncan. The drifter was a ghost of vengeance that drew his power from the town's guilty conscience. It's noteworthy that the drifter didn't just march into town and blow everyone away. In fact, at first he didn't pick a fight with anyone, even if he was there to eventually do exactly that. It's almost as if he baited them, drawing out their true, ugly underlying natures simply by existing among them. In the brutal and disturbing rape scene, the woman slammed into the drifter purposefully on the street with the intent of provoking a hostile confrontation. He wanted to walk away (or pretended to), but she wouldn't have any of it and proceeded to spit unprovoked insults and smack his cigar. His counter-insults I interpret as the ghost of Jim Duncan's vengeance stripping her of her thin pose of respectability and drawing out her truly ugly nature, the dark part of her that willingly facilitated the ex-Marshall's execution. It was only after she was drawn out that the drifter inflicted his punishment. In the context of this film, viewing that rape within a normal, decent person's ethical framework is completely off the mark.

If you want to criticize Eastwood for having a cavalier attitude toward rape, a stronger case would be with Mordecai's dumb remark that she came back at him with a gun because, maybe, he didn't "come back for more." I never liked that line, which I do think reeks of 70s style sexism.

reply

I posted she "was possibly the town whore" - that's a suggestion and an opinion.

You posted "She wasn't the town whore" - that's a statement of fact, and facts need to be proven, they need to be substantiated.

So.......please substantiate your claim or shut up and stop making that claim.

Clear enough, little girl?

reply

She is not a prostitute.

I'm not a little girl.

reply

She is not a prostitute.
That's just alternate terminology, and still not in any way substantiation or proof of your claim.

That's the way a child would respond, which is my basis for considering you to be a little girl.

reply

The correct terminology would be Ho.

Talking about yourself as a child.

reply

Just a spoiled little brat craving attention - that is what you are, that is all you are. How pathetic.

reply

[deleted]

I ain't spoiled. I worked for everything I have. You don't even know me.

reply

I ain't spoiled.
I beg to differ.
I worked for everything I have.
Possibly, but everyone does - so what?
You don't even know me.
Ahhh, just one more thing I can be thankful for....

reply

If you knew me you would like me. Most people do.

reply

Really? Are you so sensitive? Stop finding bugs in such irrelevant details. Clint is an artist who expresses his artistic side in his way and he always said that he hates violence. And by putting shocking violence in his movies, it's his way to express his hate and it's a way to critic it. Every directors have their own way to express themselves, and if he made it so far, it's because all these scenes made sens, no matter how a sensitive a little boy like you will get offended.

reply

How many of those films also depict violence against men?

reply