Two questions



Early on, Vito tell Sonny “ never tell anyone outside the family what you’re thinking” But it seems to me in the meeting with the five families he tells them a great deal about his thinking.

At the wedding, I sensed some antipathy for Tom from Michael. "He’s not Sicilian but he’s a good lawyer” is kind of cold. Later they do have conflicts. Am I imagining this early antipathy or is there something to it?

reply

Early on, Vito tell Sonny “ never tell anyone outside the family what you’re thinking” But it seems to me in the meeting with the five families he tells them a great deal about his thinking.


Vito told Sollazzo only what he wanted Sollazzo to know - which was that Vito thought drugs were a dirty business that would cause problems in the long run (losing political protection). Sonny however essentially told Sollozzo that he would be willing to go for the drug deal if their money investment was guaranteed. It was at that moment that Sollozzo knew that Vito had to go and that he had a chance to make that deal with Sonny.

At the wedding, I sensed some antipathy for Tom from Michael. "He’s not Sicilian but he’s a good lawyer” is kind of cold. Later they do have conflicts. Am I imagining this early antipathy or is there something to it?


Michael was close to Tom but changed towards him as he took over the family responsibility from Vito and did so from the moment an attempt was made on Vito's life. He got deeper and deeper and became more and more ruthless right to the end, but his "he's not a Sicilian" was not a slight.



reply

I wonder what would’ve happened if Vito had died from being shot. Obviously Michael would never end up joining the Family, but would Tom and Sonny have been forced to do business with Sollozzo and Tattaglia?

reply

Hagan told Sonny that if Vito dies he needed to make the deal.

reply

OP is referring to the meeting with the five families, but your point applies there too - Vito tells people what they need to hear to further his interests, but doesn’t reveal what he’s thinking. What he’s thinking is what he later reveals in the car - that he has worked out who was behind everything - Barzini.

reply

Thanks. It makes sense. As I recall there also may have been some slight distance because he had discussed Michael's future with his father before Michael joined the army and Michael was not thrilled about that.

reply

About the Hagen question - I don’t think the line “He’s not Sicilian” was meant to be an insult or anything. Michael and Hagen were all right at this point

They do have conflicts later, but Michael has conflicts with basically everyone in Part 2, as he becomes a ruthless and stone-hearted don. He ends that movie basically sitting by himself after he lost everyone he loved

reply