MovieChat Forums > The Andy Griffith Show (1960) Discussion > Most liked and most despised guest chara...

Most liked and most despised guest character


I really liked seeing Barbara Eden as the manicurist, but I could not stomach Michael J. Pollard as cousin Virgil. What are your most liked and most despised guest characters?

reply

I liked Bill Bixby as the spoiled young man who learned a lesson from Andy about standing on his own two feet.

Always enjoyed Denver Pyle's appearances as Brisco Darling. Loved Howard Morris as Ernest T. Bass. Enjoyed James Best as the guitar player Jim.

I liked all of Allen Melvin's appearances.He played a variety of characters including Myrt's accomplice, the lady who sold Barney her "late husband Bernard's" car. That brings me to Ellen Corby as Myrt. She was so believable as a con artist, hard to believe she became Grandma Walton!

Cousin Virgil was not a favorite of mine but he was okay.

Actually The Andy Griffith Show had a great bunch of guest actors including William Schallert who was on TV everywhere in those days!

I can't think of any guests that annoyed me as much as Aunt Bea! Francis Bavier. She had a number of good episodes. But when her voice would go all high pitched and shrieky, like a dog whistle, it hurt my ears. lol . And some of the episodes that featured her were my least favorites. Aunt Bee always seemed to be upset or crying over something. The one with her old beau Roger set my teeth on edge. Well it was really Roger and his lame , cornball jokes. I don't blame Andy for disliking the guy and worrying that he'd be his new uncle!

reply

Oh, that Roger Hanover may have been the worst after all. What a piece of work he was... and I have to agree about Aunt Bee... she drove me crazy at times.

reply

I liked just about every guest star.

My least favorites were the Darlings. I couldn't fathom the one who played the daughter for some reason.

reply

Why didn't you "fathom" Charlene Darling? aka Mrs. Dud Wash. Just curious about that. I thought she was an interesting character. She had a big crush on Andy, even to the point of naming her daughter after him, "Andalila" I think that's how it would be spelled.

Of course the feminine of Andrew is Andrea. Andalila just seemed more 'country'. I used to wonder if Charlene's husband, Dud Wash, was curious about why his wife wanted to name their daughter after the sheriff in Mayberry! Maybe he realized that Charlene had a crush on Andy and he didn't want to rock the boat.

reply

I recently had the preternatural experience of seeing Don Rickles as a guest character, the day before news of his death appeared online. I had decided to watch the episode on a whim when I saw his name appear in the opening credits.

It was a simple, straightforward, even sympathetic performance of a chronic loser. Noticeably absent was the abrasiveness associated with his comedy routines.

reply

Gee, can't believe I forgot that one! Good episode. In addition to being funny, Don Rickles was a fine actor.

reply

Most liked:
-- Bernard Fox as Malcolm Merriweather
-- Jack Prince as Rafe Hollister
-- William Schallert as Sam Becker
-- James Best as Jim Lindsey
-- Sterling Holloway as Bert Miller
-- Mary Grace Canfield as Mary Grace Gossage
-- Jesse Pearson as Keevy Hazelton
-- Woody Chambliss as Harlan Robinson & Mr. Hendricks
-- Alan Hale Jr. as Big Jeff Pruitt
-- Nancy Malone as Dr. Edith Gibson

Most disliked:
-- Wallace Ford as Roger Hanover
-- Jean Carson & Joyce Jameson as Daphne & Skippy
-- Fred Sherman as Fred Goss
-- Everett Sloane as Jubal Foster
-- John Dehner as Colonel Harvey
-- Doris Dowling as Madelyn Grayson
-- Allan Melvin as Neal, Fred Plummer, & Clyde Plaunt
-- James Westerfield as Uncle Ollie

reply