With Witness for the Prosecution, 12 Angry Men, Paths of Glory, The Seventh Seal, The Bridge on the River Kwai, Wild Strawberries, A Face in the Crowd, and Sweet Smell of Success, is 1957 the best year for film ever? I believe it's up there.
Having only seen Witness for the Prosecution, 12 Angry Men and The Bridge on the River Kwai, I can say it was an amazing year and could easily tie with 1939, 1940, 1950 and 1976 as one of the best years in film.
The Godfather Part II Chinatown The Conversation Alice Doesn't Live Here Anymore Profumo di donna Young Frankenstein Sandakan 8 Lacombe Lucien The Deluge Lenny The Towering Inferno, among others."
Others like:
Blazing Saddles Black Christmas The Texas Chainsaw Massacre The Man with the Golden Gun
I was actually thinking about this some more, and I wanted to post a summary for a few more recent years. Check out 1999.
Fight Club The Matrix American Beauty The Green Mile The Sixth Sense Magnolia The Straight Story Toy Story 2 Office Space Being John Malkovich The Boondock Saints Ghost Dog: The Way of the Samurai Sleepy Hollow Princess Mononoke Lock, Stock and Two Smoking Barrels South Park: Bigger Longer & Uncut American Psycho Dogma American Pie
Now how about 2006? Most underrated year?
The Departed The Lives of Others The Prestige Pan's Labyrinth Blood Diamond Letters from Iwo Jima Children of Men Casino Royale Little Miss Sunshine Death Note The Fall The Pursuit of Happyness Apocalypto 300 Lucky Number Slevin The Last King of Scotland Stranger Than Fiction United 93 Inside Man An Inconvenient Truth Fearless The Illusionist This Film Is Not Yet Rated
Departed or United 93 is proof for what again? Its impossible to compare todays content consumer trash with real film making of the past. You wont get good movies anymore. This is impossible cause of global marketing (avoids any base for good story telling and good jokes) and woke fascism. Movie making is history. There are now and then some miracles (like Joker) but they are just exceptions proofing the fact.
Possibly the best of the 1950´s - alongside 1950 which had to offer Sunset Blvd, Les Enfants Terribles, D.O.A., All About Eve, The Asphalt Jungle, Panic In The Streets, Rashomon, Where The Sidewalk Ends, Winchester ´73, Night And The City... However, pretty much every year from 1971 to 1976 (plus 1979) is better than each of these.
Easily 1966, although a terrible year for Hollywood: Andrei Rublev, Persona, The Good the Bad and the Ugly, The Battle of Algiers, Blow-up, Who's Afraid of Virginia Woolf, Au Hasard Balthazar, Maculin Feminin. 1962 also very good.
Fran Kubelik: 'When you're in love with a married man you shouldn't wear mascara'- The Apartment
OP: 1957 was indeed a formidable year on the strength of the first three mentioned. Bridge impressed me less, and the others leave me no more than lukewarm. But just for the first three, 1957 is most definitely in the running.
1965 is a strong contender for me: Doctor Zhivago, unquestionably one of the top 2 films of all time. Cat Ballou The Collector The Flight of the Phoenix In Harm's Way, the most underrated war movie ever made. The Ipcress File The Spy Who Came in from the Cold Those Magnificent Men in their Flying Machines Von Ryan's Express
1962 another contender for me: Lawrence of Arabia, unquestionably one of the top 2 films of all time. Advise and Consent Billy Budd How the West was Won Lolita The Longest Day Requiem for a Heavyweight To Kill a Mockingbird
1962 marked the stunningly triumphant entry of each of two most excellent and durable actors, Peter O'Toole and Terence Stamp.
This brings back some memories. 8 years later I rank 1957 as my 9th favorite year, but for a lot of different reasons that I once did. Top 10:
1. Decision at Sundown 2. The Lonely Man 3. Paths of Glory 4. Le Notti Bianche 5. The Tin Star 6. The Seventh Seal 7. Il Grido 8. The Tall T 9. Sweet Smell of Success 10. 12 Angry Men
River Kwai, Wild Strawberries, and the whole reason for this post - Witness for the Prosecution - don't do nearly as much for me as they once did.
For what it's worth, my favorite year for film is now 1948:
1. Raw Deal 2. Yellow Sky 3. Louisiana Story 4. Blood on the Moon 5. Portrait of Jennie 6. Moonrise 7. Johnny Belinda 8. Hollow Triumph aka The Scar 9. Rope 10. He Walked by Night
Hard to argue with that. Was an incredible year for films all round. Any of those films could've won Best Picture in another year. Especially when you consider Around The World In 80 Days and Gigi won the Oscar either side of it