MovieChat Forums > 12 Angry Men (1957) Discussion > 12 angry (white) men and no women

12 angry (white) men and no women



Were there no women allowed in jury's in the '50s? And no blacks or other minorities?
That's like asking for a biased judicial system.

reply

"12 Angry Men" is a good and catchy title, compared to, e.g. "7 Angry Men And 5 Angry Women, 2 Of Them Being Black".

reply

"12 Angry Men" is a good and catchy title, compared to, e.g. "7 Angry Men And 5 Angry Women, 2 Of Them Being Black".
Excellent point!
I give my respect to those who have earned it; to everyone else, I'm civil.

reply

I'm sure women were allowed and minorities might have voted less often. That is how jury selection is done in the US. Names picked at random from voting records, then they narrow the pool down to 12.

Maybe the defense or prosecution thought 12 men would be more advantageous towards getting a certain verdict.

"America isn't ready for a gay, mexican chicken sandwich" - Poultrygeist

reply

Waaaaaaaaaaah, gender quotas! Waaaaaaaaah, racial quotas! Waaaaaaaaah, waaaaaaaaa, waaaaaaaaah, superficial skin-deep statistics that are meaningless when considering people's humanity! Waaaaaaaaaah! Skin color this! Body parts that! Look how un-racist I am!

"Does your society have any other adjectives besides 'great'?" - Pvt. Church

reply

If they called it 12 Angry Men, and put a woman in it, it would just sound stupid. If they changed the title and called it 12 Angry People, it would just sound stupid.

reply

Hey OP, would you mind stop thinking of stuff based on peoples' gender or the colour of their skin? it's just that it's a bit sexist/racist, you know.

Do ponies make you angry?

reply

An addendum: to complain about there being too many whites might seem okay for you to do. Just replace 'whites' with 'blacks', it doesn't seem so okay anymore does it? racism is racism no matter what ethnicity it's aimed at. Honestly, as a white person, this kind of stuff bothers me. End racism completely. Don't just focus it all on one particular race and act like it's okay.

Do ponies make you angry?

reply

Except black people are not the privileged majority. I can't believe that there still are idiots who come up with this reverse racism BS

reply

[deleted]

You politically correct thickos never cease to talk out of your asses. They made a re-make with blacks and other races on it. What else do you want? Christ...

reply

THere were still no women in the remake.

I have no problem with the original given that in capital cases, prosecutors may have excused every prospective woman for fear that they would be reluctant to impose the death penalty.

However, in modern productions, many of the roles are in fact played by women.

reply

Surprised that you didn't say "liberals". That would make you the "thicko"

reply

So what's your point? I thought it was common sense by now that political correctness was for children.

reply

Just sounds like a damn good jury to me...

reply

Interesting, I just read an article in the New York TImes today, talking about a 90 year old man who's worked as the jury summoner in New York City for the past 45 years.THe article noted that until relatively recently, a woman could claim an exemption from jury duty simply by being a woman.

reply

They didn't have to pay for dates or fight in wars, either. It must have been nice.

reply