Wrong, wrong, wrong
His pinched, elfin features are sort of cute, I suppose, and I can see why some young girls would like him, but he's utterly wrong for Finnick Odair. Seriously, this kid should be on the cover of Lisa Simpson's "Non-Threatening Boys" magazine.
Finnick is supposed to be bronzed, outdoorsy and impossibly handsome. Sam Claflin is the cutest boy in a middle school's chess club. Seriously. Can you imagine him stabbing someone with a trident? Finnick needs a ferocious edge, a killer instinct, that I just don't get from little British schoolboy Claflin.