Yes Dewey Cox was awful and yes I do listen to music and yes I do watch music movies including all the ones you mentioned. The film does make references to many movies and other musicians and therein lies the problem. It tries to cram in as much as it can, a lot of it sketchily, the targets were too obvious as was the humour. Subtle it ain't. I did see the extended version and at times I got the impression that the director didn't like to shout cut. For example in the Beatles section it was funny for the first 20 seconds, but the it just went on an on and on. My main problem was with John C Reilly, who is a great character actor but comedy is not his forte, who would take a joke and hammer it into the ground and then stomp on it. It was no great surprise when I learn't that he got the job because he could sing, unlike say Will Ferrel who would have made a better choice, and as I mentioned Jenna was hopeless. The film was one of the few films Judd Apatow was involved with that failed at the box office, and I can understand why. You didn't mention the greatest and funniest music film ever made, This Is Spinal Tap, now that's how to do it properly.
reply
share