Who was prettier and the better actress ?

Damn, I'm kind of stumped on this one. I don't find either character that attractive, but still it's hard to say which one is better.

They were both pretty when they were younger, in certain photographs at least, and they both did good enough when it came to acting. I'd go with Talia Shire, especially as she looked in these two pictures:

https://i.imgur.com/F9qdNcx.jpg

https://i.imgur.com/kqe8LIX.jpg

I like her smile (especially the shape of her teeth and the way they slant inward slightly), and she has bigger boobs than Fisher did.

I'll take the Guinea brat.

I think Carrie Fisher was really beautiful when she was younger. Unfortunately, she didn't age very well (I thought she was a good actress, though). On the flip side, I think Talia Shire aged very well and got more attractive as she got older.

Acting-wise, I have to go with Talia Shire. I thought she was great in both The Godfather and Rocky series of movies. She's probably one of my favorite actresses, now that I think about it.

Carrie Fisher

Talia Shire is the better actress. I don't find either of them attractive.

Both are very pretty but I’d say Talia Shire was a bit more so.

I really disliked her characters in The Godfather III and Rocky II movies, I thought she was very annoying but that’s not really her fault, that was just bad writing.

Fisher might've been cute early on, but neither are pretty.

Shire is the better actress.