MovieChat Forums > General Discussion > Was Adolf Hitler the most historically s...

Was Adolf Hitler the most historically significant person of the 20th century?


Well? Who else would it be? Einstein? Gandhi?

reply

The argument could definitely be made that Hitler was the most influential person of the 20th century. Does that mean that he did a lot of good? No. Does that mean he wasn't a total bastard? Of course not. But the events he set into motion last century are still rippling today.

Getting back to the real topic, what's your favorite movie about Hitler?

reply

If I may butt in...
Hitler in Inglourious Basterds when he gets chopped up by machine gun fire and is left to roast in a burning building was a performance for the ages😬

reply

Haha, that scene was hoot! :-D

This just made me realize how every Tarantino flick since Kill Bill ends in a gloriously fun ballet of violence. He's probably going to pull out all the stops for his final project.

reply

Tarantino seems to like talking about his final movie:/

I really enjoy his films and hope he's still directing in several decades

reply

Spoilers! Now I know there's a luau at the end of the film.

reply

Favorites (in no particular order)

Downfall (Bruno Ganz)
Hitler: The Last Ten Days (Alec Guinness)
The Winds of War (TV miniseries) (Günter Meisner)
War and Remembrance (TV miniseries) (Steven Berkoff)
The Bunker (TV movie) (Anthony Hopkins)
Hitler: The Rise of Evil (TV miniseries) (Robert Carlyle)
I'll Never Heil Again (Three Stooges short) (Moe Howard) - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BtmkzLknVy4

OVERALL FAVORITE: Günter Meisner

reply

I watched Nosferatu (1979) last night with Bruno Ganz and I kept thinking surly Ganz would stop Dracula in his tracks at any moment with a Hitler like tirade! Lol

His performance in Downfall was amazing.

reply

He should have won an Oscar for that performance! Downfall didn't even win best foreign language film that year.

reply

I agree.

reply

You already did this topic:
https://moviechat.org/nm0386944/Adolf-Hitler/5f28b8038c8ce12918f5adce/Most-famous-person-of-the-20th-century

And the answer is Luke Skywalker. He killed the Death Star with almost no training.

reply

But that was a long time ago in a galaxy far away...

reply

Interesting question...

I'd say FDR
But Hitler was most certainly one of the biggest people on the stage

reply

That's a real intriguing take, and if you'd like to elaborate on the pick, I'm all ears. I don't dispute FDR's position as a major figure, but from what I'm aware, Hitler holds a higher hand in shaping international relations into what we see today.

reply

I have to disagree
FDR guided (not always ably to be fair) a vast, stumbling country into an agricultural and industrial powerhouse while the whole time juggling foreign and domestic troubles

Honestly, Adolf was playing checkers and FDR was playing chess

Here in America we still benefit from some of FDR's economic programs and the Presidents that followed him carried on with the same appropriate American self interest internationally and a high level of suspicion towards fascism and communism anywhere

Hitler was a lucky lunatic that got way farther along than he should ever have

reply

Yes. The consequences of Hitler's WW2 threw Western Civilization into its death spiral and it doesn't get much more historically significant than that.

reply

How would the world be different today if Hitler was never around?

reply

Ah, difficult question but I'll play anyway. America bankrupted England with its Lend Lease deal for war materiel in WW2 and that combined with the ruin inflicted by fighting two world wars meant that the already faltering British Empire was done and England sank into serious decline. To the extent that England embodied Western Civilisation and I think you can make an argument that more than any other country it did then that is one of the chief differences if Hitler had never existed and WW2 had never happened.



reply

Hi, I live in The Western Civilization area
Can you describe the symptoms of the 'death spiral' I should be experiencing right now or am I on your block list?

Also, the expansionist policies of The Empire Of Japan had at least a little bit to do with WWII...but, no matter, it's not like they did anything horrible like the Nazis...

reply

Well if you can't or weren't around to see the decline in standards over the past fifty years for yourself then it might be difficult to believe. But here goes with a quick grab bag in no particular order:

- Once being a Professor meant something. Now there are thousands of mediocre hacks at Universities with the job title.
- Once Governments used to actually govern instead of ducking every decision and engaging in a continuous election campaign as their main function.
- The Civil Service believe it or not used to be professionally run by competent people not the Keystone Cops outfits we are saddled with these days.
- Western Civilisation was synonymous with white Europeans. Now mass immigration, "multi-culturalism" and globalisation have well and truly begun the process that will finish it off once and for all.

That's enough to be going on with.



reply

Sounds like a usual Tuesday from where I'm sitting...

The real takeaway is I'm not on your 'ignore' lost

That's fascinating

reply


He was an evil and insane bastard, but he's probably in the top five. I'd also throw in the great Winston Churchill.

😎

reply

I'm sure he's had the most documentaries made about him

reply

Alexander Fleming, who discovered penicillin and spearheaded antibiotics in general.

reply

he saved a lot of lives.

reply

You posted a similar topic on the Adolf Hitler board two weeks ago, with 45 replies. Why again?

ಠ▄ಠ

reply