MovieChat Forums > General Discussion > Pick a movie, change the director.

Pick a movie, change the director.


Pick a movie that you think would be interesting with another director. The movie doesn't have to be bad, but more of a "it would be interesting if so and so directed this movie". Try to keep it realistic. Don't say something like Alfred Hitchcock directing Titanic because he wouldn't have been alive when the film came out.

Magnolia - Ingmar Bergman
Rocky - Martin Scorsese
Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind - Spike Jonze
Heat - David Fincher
Back to the Future - James Cameron
Pan's Labyrinth - Tim Burton
Parasite - Paul Thomas Anderson

reply

So if Orson Welles does It's a Wonderful Life (1946), does Mr. Potter win, and George Bailey not make it out of the river alive?

It’s a Blunderful Life?

reply

I do the puns around here, okay?

reply

Gotta defend your turf😬

reply

The nerve of some people.

reply

Ignoring OP's era-eligibility,
Would have preferred ...

Batman 89: Sam Peckinpah
Skyfall and Specter: Mathew Vaughn
Star Trek Into Darkness & Beyond: Quintin Tarantino
Star Wars sequels: James Cameron
League of Extraordinary Gentlemen: Del Toro or Gilliam
Ghostbusters 2016: Wes Craven w/ Clive Barker writing
Suicide Squad: John McTiernan
Dunkirk: Spielberg
SW Solo: Steven Soderbergh
Pearl Harbor: Kubrik
Babylon AD: Yuen Woo Ping

Would not have preferred but still like to have seen ...

Wonder Woman: Paul Verhoeven
Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy: Wes Anderson
The Crow: Fincher
Natural Born Killers: Coen Bros
Bourne movies: Guy Ritchie

I could go on and on.

reply

"Star Wars sequels: James Cameron"

As a long time Star Wars fan... I wish!

reply

Star Trek Into Darkness & Beyond: Quintin Tarantino

Maybe, maybe, you could see that happening. Chances are low, that's true, but there's a Tarantino Star Trek project and it's not completely abandoned yet.
https://www.imdb.com/title/tt7713358/
https://www.indiewire.com/2020/01/quentin-tarantino-star-trek-exit-1202203086/

Suicide Squad: John McTiernan

Fucking this^^^

In general, I want fucking McTiernan back. He's one of the best action directors ever, how the hell he's unemployed! And Suicide Squad would have been perfect for him.

SW Solo: Steven Soderbergh

Yes and no. I think the scifi genre needs new blood. A Soderbergh scifi movie? that would be interesting. However, I don't see him doing a Star Wars space opera movie about Han Solo.

League of Extraordinary Gentlemen: Del Toro or Gilliam

Drooling here. Del Toro would have been just perfect.

Skyfall and Specter: Mathew Vaughn

Anything but another Kingsman movie (he's gonna release the 3rd one). Mathew Vaughn is one of the very few decent directors right now, and he's wasting his talent in the Kingsman series.

Dunkirk: Spielberg

Not really. I mean: we already had that movie, it was Saving Private Ryan. I think Mel Gibson would be a better option. He did great in Hacksaw Ridge, but we don't have his WW2 movie in the European theater yet.

Wonder Woman: Paul Verhoeven

A very interesting choice. In general, I just would like to see a superhero movie made by Verhoeven. Sadly, Hollywood will never have the courage to do that.

Bourne movies: Guy Ritchie

Heavily disagree here. Ritchie shines in movies that allow him to move in a blurry area between action and parody. His best movies, it's hard to say when he's being serious and when he's being parodic. I don't think he's a good fit for Bourne.

Ghostbusters 2016: Wes Craven w/ Clive Barker writing

Clive Barker writing Ghostbusters? That could be great. Of course, that would mean Ghosbusters going straight into horror and lovecraftian territory... and why not?

reply

Exactly! Why isn't McTiernan working? They hold up all of their other other criminals on their shoulders. He has been out of jail for awhile. I had wanted him for directing Captain America but the law and justice and all that.

I think Soderbergh is good for Solo because of the whole suave smuggler angle. Maybe Pete Travis for a more kinetic, cohesive shoot'em up.

You didn't like the first Kingsmen? I liked it more than the last three 007 movies. I don't saddle him with the comedy. He certainly is in the top 3 of modern directors in my book.

I wanted Dunkirk to be great. I had long studied the battle and was excited about the movie. Nolan did some things well but the movie is a mess. I guess Spielberg is a knee-jerk choice based on proof of acumen in the genre. But you're right. Would likely be too similar.

Verhoeven movies are bright and violent. Would liked to have seen his portrayal of the Amazons (instead of the mildly cringey stuff we got). He is perfect for capeshit.

I loved what Ritchie did with Man from UNCLE. Dial down the antics a little and I think he would be great for the multi-tiered story lines of a Ludlum movie with its bursts of violence in between slick interaction. The Bourne movies were serviceable shakey cam action movies (I liked the Renner one best, tbhwy) but they felt soulless to me. Probably Damon and not the director.

Imagine if Girl-Ghostbusters was mostly serious. Like 85/15 horror/comedy. Would have done better. Kill off a few of them. Show true terror. The higher stakes would have been better fertilizer for the jokes.

reply

The Room (2003)- Donald Trump

“It’ll be a terrific movie, a wonderful movie...I know more about directing than the greats like Ford, DeMille, Kubrick, Scorsese, Keerwaseewa, whatever his name is...people always tell me ‘wow, you’re so good with this directing stuff, who knew?’....I may star and direct my own biopic since Phillip Seymour Hoffman can’t do it... yeah, it’ll be great, sellouts like my rallies...it’ll be yuge...bigly....tremendous...”

reply

The Iceman (2012) - Martin Scorsese

reply

That would be awesome.

reply

Mr. Magorium's Wonder Emporium: Terry Gilliam

reply

Even the title sounds like a Gilliam movie.

reply

Exactly!

reply

Conan The Barbarian (1982) - Oliver Stone.

reply

In Oliver Stone's case, it's more like Cocaine the Barbarian, amirite?

reply

Well I thought since he wrote the screenplay....

reply

This is copied from another thread with a twist:

Jaws directed by Keenen Ivory Wayans


New cast will include:

Redd Foxx as Quint
Richard Roundtree as Brody
Jimmie Walker as Hooper
Pam Grier as Elaine Brody
Esther Anderson as Mrs Kitner
Jaleel White As Alex Kitner
Sherman Hemsley as Mayor Vaughn

reply

Who's playing the shark?

reply

Let me give that some thought.

reply

James Woods.

reply

My Girl - Wes Craven

reply

I think it would be better if My Girl didn't exist to begin with.

reply

That's sad. I've always liked that movie.

reply

McCauley CoCo with the bees?

reply

That's the movie.

reply