MovieChat Forums > General Discussion > Is it possible Stone is better than Scor...

Is it possible Stone is better than Scorsese?


Watching the Aviator the beginning is similar to Alexander but when comes to dark deep bio mindness Stone is usually more original.

reply

No.

reply

I enjoy JFK, platoon, the doors and natural born killers more than anything Scorsese has done, so yes.

He has lost his touch though, should have retired after nbk.

reply

Yea I thought some of his work was better.

And I think NBK could rival taxi as I actually put NBK as one of the best movies ever made.

What you didnt like Alexander?

reply

I never got NBK. Not sure what i'm missing. It seems right in my wheelhouse of movies i love.

reply

There is a Director’s cut.
It might help.

reply

I though alexander was long and boring. Also jolie as farrell's mother?

reply

Even the theatre cut? I kne many people that liked it.

Jolie was supposed to represent how beautiful and youthful looking his mother was that I thought was realistic. European women age well and she acted well in the part. Though I liked Colin if anything his appearance was miscasted Irish for a greek, dyed hair, irish accent?
Jolie actually played his mom from a baby till after death which made sense.

No Nixon? Come on, this is one of the best movies ever made. Way better than jfk.

reply

Just my opinion but I would say no
Stone has had some great hits but Scorsese is my favorite of the two

reply


No. Not a chance in hell! Stone is a Leftard hack.

😎

reply

Not even close. Stone is very talented, though and JFK is a masterpiece.

reply

JFK is fiction.

reply

Total fictional BS but fairly entertaining

reply

No. Simple as that.

reply

Reported.

reply