Movie characters who seemed almost surreal or supernatural

Holy Man (1998) - Eddie Murphy is a wandering mystic/philosopher called "G" who meets up with Jeff Goldblum's troubled home shopping network executive and decides to help him out by joining the network as an on-air host. Hijinks ensue. By the end, it's all but said outright that "G" is God.

I was going to offer Mr. Roarke from Fantasy Island, then I realized you were only asking about movies.

Then I began to wonder: How is it that they never made a FI movie?

Then I googled it and it turns out that a FI movie is in the works now:

https://variety.com/2018/film/news/michael-pena-mr-roarke-fantasy-island-movie-1202972610/

That's awesome you said John Ryder! I was literally about to respond to your question with that and of course you pick Ryder. I felt like he had that Jason Voorhees power in seemingly being able to be anywhere anytime.

Vinnie Jones got shot in the teeth and still beat everyone up in Lock, Stock and Two Smoking Barrels

Sam Elliott as The Stranger in The Big Lebowski (1998).

There is a movie called Funny Games with Naomi Watts and there is a scene where it seems to go unexpectedly into the surreal.

The strangers in "The Strangers" (2008)

Vince Vaughn in Brawl in the Cell 99. He beat up a car. A frickin' car. With bare hands!