Movie characters who seemed almost surreal or supernatural
Two come to mind:
The Intruder (1962) - the Adam Cramer character played by William Shatner seemed out of this world. The movie is a drama but was directed by Roger Corman so anything is possible.
The Hitcher (1986) - John Ryder played by Rutger Hauer also seems to have some supernatural powers. The movie is classified as a thriller.
Can you think of any others?