Films You Either Love or Hate

The Blair Witch Project

I think surreal, symbolic, stylized or over the top movies fit that comparison.
E.g.: Eraserhead, The Seventh Seal, Last Year at Marienbad and Mandy.

Movies from directors with a unique style
E.g.: 71 Fragmente einer Chronologie des Zufalls, Annie Hall, Dogville

Good old silent movies probably too, just because most plebs can't handle old movies.
E.g.: Cabinet of Dr. Caligary, Faust

Recently I have the feeling, at least for horror fans the A24 style is divisive
Hereditary, It comes at Night, The Vvitch,...

Armageddon
Prometheus
Die Hard 2
Police Academy 1-5

The Last Jedi

I Know What You Did Last Summer

Emoji (I watch it with my 4 year old daughter). It's universally hated and I don't understand why?

I feel like most cult classics fall into that category. The first one that comes to my mind is Donnie Darko.

Hated,

Pulp fiction
Matrix
No country for old men
Blade runner