MovieChat Forums > A Christmas Carol (2019) Discussion > Guy Pearce’s ‘A Christmas Carol’ gives t...

Guy Pearce’s ‘A Christmas Carol’ gives tale a bleak spin


https://nypost.com/2019/12/11/guy-pearces-a-christmas-carol-gives-tale-a-bleak-spin/

reply

The original book, and every filmed version of it, have been bleak. That's the point.

reply

Sure bleak elements but always with an incredibly joyful and warm payoff. The payoff in this version, while not without merit, feels so much less satisfying, less joyful, and lukewarm at best (and that's being generous). I'll also say that considering this is almost 3 hours long, the final payoff feels completely rushed and incomplete.

reply

I saw two new Christmas Carols this year, and the better one was done by the soap opera General Hospital.

reply