I know about Roger and Quentin. He argued and got co-credit on Pulp Fiction for mainly the concept of one section of Pulp Ficition and shared the Oscar that they walked on stage arm in arm to receive, and it kick started his career. His career has gone as well as Tarantino's so since then he's blabbed about every slight that he now perceives QT has done to him, in hindsight.
To say that he finally got credit is just wrong. He's always had it and it still hasn't been taken away, no matter how much he had to insist that he got it in the first place.
Aside from the gold watch story (and the whole section of dialogue in the motel bathroom where Butch and Fabienne discuss where they can afford to go with the money); the missed bullets in the apartment, the accidental shooting in the car and the gimp were all Avary's brainchild. So bottom line, if a screenplay contains significant contributions from someone that crucially impact the flow of the story isn't it logical that they are rightly entitled to full co-writing credit and shouldn't be so crassly and childishly hornswoggled out of it in place of a measly 'story by' credit as should be obvious from the book excerpt above?
Story credit and screenplay credit are not the same thing, there's a difference. Mere story content and contributing lines of dialogue and complete scenes logically merit a full hand in the screenplay its self and not mere story elements.
WGA determines how those credits are made. If Tarantino kept the concept but significantly changed the dialogue than Avary doesn't deserve a writing credit. If Avary came up with ideas that Tarantino wrote the dialogue for he doesn't get a writing credit. The amount of writing needed to earn a credit is higher than a few scenes and ideas, regardless of their significance to the plot.
He still won an Oscar for his work so I don't understand how you perceive him to have been slighted.
Well from that explanation I guess I understand better now, but from that book excerpt above you got to admit the way Quentin handled it was kind of crass and childish don't you think?
Yeah. And he got a movie produced with "From the maker of Pulp Fiction" all over the poster too. IT's not like he was ever even remotely denied recognition in the public eye.