I had zero knowledge of J.D. Vance and hadn't read the book the film was based on, but I checked this out because Ron Howard is usually a proficient director of solidly entertaining flicks that graze over history and culture.
I got what I asked for - a satisfying family drama. However, judging by the reviews, it seems like the release date of the film couldn't have been more poorly timed.
In the run-up to Donald Trump’s 2016 victory, J.D. Vance published 'Hillbilly Elegy', a book exploring the Appalachian values of his Kentucky-based family. As the subtitle indicates - “A Memoir of a Family and Culture in Crisis” - Vance had set out to describe the roots and consequences of a breakdown. At a time when many observers were puzzling over why downtrodden working-class whites would have embraced a candidate whose conduct and origins seemed so alien to their professed values, it provided some easy answers.
The book became a sensation and that sensation in turn generated a deep, slow-burning backlash. There was no way Ron Howard’s project wasn’t going to be greeted with fusillades of rhetorical buckshot from one side or the other, particularly while everyone's emotions were still churning after Trump's loss to Biden during a catastrophic year for Americans.
Not a great film but not a disaster the critics made it out to be. This was clearly politics. I'm not a democratic or republican. I just call it like I see it.
Same here. I had no idea who JD Vance is or the book, but checked it out because of Amy Adams. It was a well acted film and a good family drama. I thought it was a bit anti-climatic, but overall really good performances and a quality movie. Not sure why it gets so much hate.