John Wick versus Ethan Hunt.


By all accounts, Keanu Reeves is a nice guy. And he has done good action movies in the past.

But, he is just not believable as this ass-kicking assassin.

IMDB tells me that Reeves is almost 55... so 54-ish when he made this movie. Tom Cruise is two years older.

I can buy Tom Cruise as an effective Ethan Hunt, but I just cannot buy Keanu Reeves as a hardass assassin.

In this movie, particularly, Reeves looks heavy and slow. He runs with this bow-legged trot, his gut hanging over his belt. During the fight scenes, you can see him reacting to blows before they happen. (Even his stuff in the Matrix looks painfully robotic and staged...).

Cruise runs like a madman still, does his own stunts, many of which are professional by the standards of stuntmen. They take your breath away.

Meanwhile, the best Reeves could do was some interesting but, otherwise, forgettable stuff on a horse. (This is more a comment on the director and the stunt co-ordinator, than Reeves himself I suppose.)

PS. The bit with the parkour dogs WAS pretty original.

Story wise, the MI films are taut thrillers. The last three or four have all built on an expanding story line. The first Wick film started as a taut action flick. But the two subsequent movies have upped the mythology to the level of ludicrousness.

In some ways, the Wick films are structured like computer games... 15 minutes of action, 5 minute mundane cut scene, rinse and repeat. This movie does nothing story wise... we simply see Wick dealing with bigger and bigger bosses. This movie ends at the same point as the previous movie... Wick an outcast ready to take on hundreds more bounty hunters.

Didn't pay to watch this one, will likely skip the next altogether.

reply

I'd take five more Wicks over one more MI any day.

reply

Reeves did look slow in this movie. He should hang up the action roles.

reply

The silat guys said that Wick is slow now.

reply

I'd take Wick. One definite advantage in hand to hand I can see is that he is almost six inches taller.

reply

Which is a disadvantage. Short people can move faster. They have a lower polar moment of inertia. World-class gymnasts are tiny for a reason. The nations that developed martial art have tiny natives.

reply

Wick. All the way.

reply

Totally agree with you.(well except for the gut thing. I think it's just his shirt)
The wick films also gloss over most logic. No cops on the streets and almost everyone looking the other way when someone is killed on the street. It is more of a fantasy world like the matrix. MI movies are thriller action films.
With a structured story and logic, I prefer them much more.

Wick films are for people under 25 with short attention spans, lack of logic and still playing video games.

Mi are for people who have moved beyond all that but still like to see action films but with some semblance of Logic.

I watched the first 3 JW on blu ray but like you will probably not bother with the fourth. They are pretty much all the same. 90% killing and 10% story. They are well crafted but just too oversaturated with kill shots. It gets boring very quickly.

reply