MovieChat Forums > The Titan (2018) Discussion > Could have been so much more (no spoiler...

Could have been so much more (no spoilers)


What a complete disappointment. I love sci-fi and would even err in favor of a movie if it carried its premise to a conclusion. The first two acts are just barely mediocre. The third act goes beyond reasonableness and what suspension of disbelief can maintain. This had some real potential, but it was just really a bad movie experience. There was so much potential here. The concept is interesting. They had a fairly reasonable cast, and it bombed for me. This was a wasted opportunity for what could have been a very interesting movie. The premise of the movie itself was amazing - that rather we transform ourselves than transform a planet. This movie just did not live up to the premise, and I am sorry it didn't. It was just bad.

reply

I’m 20 minutes I’m but maybe I won’t finish it now.

reply

If you finished it, what did you think? If you didn't, then at least I saved you an hour of your life.

reply

I finished it though it put me to sleep twice. I think it was an interesting concept humans creating the aliens. How does Rick being on Titan save humanity? Were there any repercussions for Tom Sizemore’s character? The tentacle thing was just oh by the way they have tentacles too. It had some good actors but they couldn’t save the plot. Some nice cinematography I suppose.

reply

I struggled to get through it too. At 90 minutes it felt a lot longer. Nice concept but the director/writer/whoever didn't seem to know what to really do with it. Waste of good actors. The last shot was cool though.

reply

I saw the trailers and thought this was gonna be another Science gone wrong Horror movie like The Fly or Hollow Man.
It did not deliver.

Son, I'm disappoint.

reply

I dunno.... I mean yes, the idea of changing us vs changing the planet is interesting, but it seems likely that it would be easier to transform us to survive here rather than go on a desolate moon elsewhere.
In fact, the whole 'crisis' on earth was poorly described. Overpopulation, yes, but hell, decreasing our numbers ain't that hard - just go all Stallin and take out the old people. Even that is way easier than 'evolving' and going to again, a moon which doesn't have much growing on it. Or if you wanted him to live underwater on titan, then surely we got a lot more water? So what exactly was the problem on earth? We were shown mountains, rivers - the whole works - other than a few soldiers saying how earth is done for, there was absolutely no indication that there were any issues on earth - visually speaking.

So what we got was a poorly explained crisis - and a horribly made 'solution'. I mean, those soldiers weren't human anymore - you might as well send a monkey to Titan and say that they'll be the humanity's future. The fact is, Neil Tyson was right - planet Earth, even in its most inhospitable state, is by far better than any of the planets or moons in our solar system.



Spoiler:






The very ending bit was lame - soldiers turned on the mad scientist instead of the transformed soldier who has probably killed hundreds of soldiers by that point? Not likely.

reply

I can't believe how they wasted such a good concept. They could start the story with a lizard people lived happily and lonely on the Titan for a decade. And then a spaceship captured it and sent it back to the earth. Then scientists tried changing it back step by step. In the end, Human Sam Worthington reunited with his family. How hard would that be?
Changing life form to adapt the planet is nothing new. We already saw that on the alien played by Keanu in the movie "The Day the Earth Stood Still". One step forward of the idea is: if we can do it once, why can't we do it again and again - go to the titan, back to the earth, go to any new planet we want...

reply

Indeed a very interesting concept but a failure in the end.

reply

it seems so

reply