Should they do it without Bill Murray?

They should not put an end to the film or hold it up just to please the fans. A new generation of characters can work as seen with Star Trek. They can do a Venkman type character in the new team.

Like with 2016 GB the film is in a rock and a hard place fans want Bill Murray but that's never gonna happen.

It's nearly always best to go with unknowns or young up and coming actors in these films supported by established actors.

I'm going to disagree, and say they shouldn't copy the original team too closely. The new team need to have distinct personalities, people the audience can respond to in their own right, and not actors who are imitating the original team. Of course the team will need to be similar to the old team in that there needs to be an engineer and at least one paranormal expert, and IMHO by now it'll be necessary to include a programmer to make all the computer and wireless components work.


The 2016 remake actually got that right, and also included an expert on local history, which was a good idea. If only they'd included more laughs, the movie might have been a complete success!