Authenticity


Although the show isn't that bad, it left me with lots of questions and I wish they put a little more effort into the details.
For instance, quite a few of the chaps had long hair, at least for the era.
The explosives guy practically looked like he stepped straight out of 1960s London.

I was also wondering why and how they would contact Canada with their suitcase radio.
As far as I know those radios had a reach of about 500 miles, not 5000.
And Canada was part of the British Empire at the time, so I assumed they would/should just contact Special Force Headquarters in London.

And maybe I misunderstood, but really?
After they were involved in a top secret raid all the way in occupied Europe these 4 agents get picked up, flown back all the way to Canada (would have taken days, there is a war going on after all) and still wearing the same clothes are debriefed?
That is a bit odd.
Most of these groups would stay as long as they could and IF they were called back, they would go to England, not half across the world.

The whole story would have been made a lot more believable if they had not insisted on making part of the story take place in Canada.
Why not just pick a special Canadian branch of SOE situated in England?

History like this is important enough to take serious and put some effort into getting even the details right.
If you spot mistakes, especially ones that could easily have been avoiding, it is just a sign of somebody not doing their job properly.

Besides that the story was a bit over the top but not too bad and I think it is entertaining and may teach kids a few things about the war.
I'll give it another go but am not too impressed by the first episode so far.


Complaining about mistakes is almost as bad as complaining about complaining about mistakes.

reply

some of the stuff is disputed...but, this is what was said on wikepedia...

so William Stephenson...was born in Manitoba....so he was like I said, a british subject.......because he was born before 47...but he was born in Canada, all the same...

hey both my parents, were british subjects.....as they were born before 47......and all of those that are born before 47...which is still a lot of people....so

susan

Sir William Samuel Stephenson, Kt, CC, MC, DFC (23 January 1897 – 31 January 1989) was a Canadian soldier, airman, businessman, inventor, spymaster, and the senior representative of British intelligence for the entire western hemisphere during World War II. He is best known by his wartime intelligence codename Intrepid. Many people consider him to be one of the real-life inspirations for James Bond.[2] Ian Fleming himself once wrote, "James Bond is a highly romanticized version of a true spy. The real thing is ... William Stephenson."[3]

As head of the British Security Coordination, Stephenson handed over British scientific secrets to Franklin D. Roosevelt and relayed American secrets to Winston Churchill.[4] In addition, Stephenson has been credited with changing American public opinion from an isolationist stance to a supportive tendency regarding America's entry into World War II.[4]

Many of the claims about him in the 1976 biography A Man Called Intrepid by the British-born Canadian author William Stevenson have since been disputed; see "Disputes" below.



Contents 
1 Early life
2 Interbellum
3 World War II
4 Honours
5 Legacy
6 Disputes
7 Popular culture
8 See also
9 Notes
10 References
11 External links


§Early life[edit]

Stephenson was born William Samuel Clouston Stanger on 23 January 1897, in Point Douglas, Winnipeg, Manitoba. His mother was from Iceland, and his father was from the Orkney Islands. He was adopted early by an Icelandic family after his parents could no longer care for him, and given his foster parents' name, Stephenson.

He left school at a young age and worked as a telegrapher. In January 1916, in World War I, he volunteered for service in the 101st Overseas Battalion (Winnipeg Light Infantry), Canadian Expeditionary Force. He left for England on the S.S. Olympic on 29 June 1916, arriving on 6 July 1916. The 101st Battalion was broken up in England, and he was transferred to the 17th Reserve Battalion in East Sandling, Kent. On 17 July he was transferred to the Canadian Engineer Training Depot. He was attached to the Sub Staff, Canadian Training Depot Headquarters, in Shorncliffe, and was promoted to Sergeant (with pay of Clerk) in May 1917. In June 1917 he was "on command" to the Cadet Wing of the Royal Flying Corps at Denham Barracks, Buckinghamshire.

On 15 August 1917, Stephenson was officially struck off the strength of the Canadian Expeditionary Force and granted a commission in the Royal Flying Corps.[5] Posted to 73 Squadron on 9 February 1918, he flew the Sopwith Camel biplane fighter and scored 12 victories to become a flying ace before he was shot down and crashed his plane behind enemy lines on 28 July 1918. During the incident Stephenson was injured by fire from a German ace pilot, Justus Grassmann,[6] by friendly fire from a French observer,[7] or by both. In any event he was subsequently captured by the Germans and held as a prisoner of war until he managed to escape in October 1918.[7]

By the end of World War I, Stephenson had achieved the rank of Captain and earned the Military Cross and the Distinguished Flying Cross. His medal citations perhaps foreshadow his later achievements, and read:


For conspicuous gallantry and devotion to duty. When flying low and observing an open staff car on a road, he attacked it with such success that later it was seen lying in the ditch upside down. During the same flight he caused a stampede amongst some enemy transport horses on a road. Previous to this he had destroyed a hostile scout and a two-seater plane. His work has been of the highest order, and he has shown the greatest courage and energy in engaging every kind of target.
- Military Cross citation, Supplement to the London Gazette, 22 June 1919.


This officer has shown conspicuous gallantry and skill in attacking enemy troops and transports from low altitudes, causing heavy casualties. His reports, also, have contained valuable and precise information. He has further proved himself a keen antagonist in the air, having, during recent operations, accounted for six enemy aeroplanes.
- Distinguished Flying Cross citation, Supplement to the London Gazette, 21 September 1928.

reply

compared to Flashpoint, yes there are mistakes. But it's still watchable.

reply

[deleted]