MovieChat Forums > The Predator (2018) Discussion > Actually a good action comedy

Actually a good action comedy


Not sure how the true blue Predator fans will take it but the gore, characters, action, and irreverent humor was enough for me. It's enjoyable if not a great Predator film.

Have a short review of this movie if anyone is interested. Enjoy! Review here - https://youtu.be/X9e1s7BDc2g

reply

Comedy?

reply

like a black comedy. it goes well with the gore

reply

Which predator movies did you prefer?
How would you rate this against those?
Is there any other movie you think this is kind of similar to?

reply

first one of course is the best. That Adrien Brody one that came out a couple years ago was ok. This is pretty close to that I think. I don't really think much of the others.

reply

Thank you - seems it will be a middle of the road movie - sill have to watch it.

Predator obviously gets the full 10 marks and sets the benchmark in terms of action/horror/stars and arnold's muscles/quips puts a few points towards that.

Predator 2 - gets a bad rep - I think the second one was just as about as good as they come in terms of a predator sequel without the 80's bigger hitters like the first one - maybe an 8 from me for that.

Predators - not bad but super predators were shite got taken out too easy - no challenge and no star power apart from danny trego who gets taken out first - 5.5

AVPs suck - big waste.

reply

So its a mix ooon action and ooon comedy???

reply

I foresee dozens of “true” Predator fans NOT being pleased and amused by this. Lol

But, yeah, it’s being called a surprisingly funny movie (irreverently so). Although given that it’s Shane Black behind the wheel, it shouldn’t come as a surprise that he brought his brand of black humor to this.

Do I mind? Not one bit. Could be refreshing for the franchise (sure the original has its funny bits but a comedy it ain’t). Besides the characters in this look like they’re having fun. So mixed reception aside, I am excited for it.

reply

Same. I had a lot of fun with these characters though.

reply

The movie is kind of a mess, 5/10.

reply

it's not a very cohesive plot. I thought the gore and characters were fun tho

reply

It's a funny movie, very entertaining, and in my opinion the plot is "cohesive".
That's what I wrote in May this year on another site:


In the meantime rewatched Predator (2018) and enoyed it…again. ♥
The happenings in the movie aren't illogical.

SPOILER - SPOILER - SPOILER - SPOILER - SPOILER - SPOILER
The mini-Predator crashes into the earth with his spaceship.
He falls right into McKenna-team's special action against the drug lords.
Then the mini-Predator is unconscious.
The main hero, sniper McKenna, takes part of his equipment.
When the mini-Predator later wakes up in the lab, everything has been taken from him, he's pinned to the table and gruesome aliens 👽 (humans) stare at him.
Even the most peaceful savior would go nuts.
So, the mini-Predator frees himself, assassinates almost everyone and is chased by the army to the school. The maxi-Predator catches him there.
That was it with the mini-Predator. 🥴​

At the very end the surviving human heroes find the Predator suit, thinking it's a gift from the mini-Predator to humanity. Plausibly, cause they can use it as a prototype for alien technology and develop more combat suits out of it.

Whether the suit was really a gift from the mini-Predator can be doubted.
Perhaps the mini-Predator only took this combat suit with him when he fled, cause it was his only chance to survive against the maxi-Predator. 🐗​

reply

Your standards must be really low then. Sorry to hear that.

reply