MovieChat Forums > Rogue One (2016) Discussion > Where do you stand on this film?

Where do you stand on this film?


A) Best film in the series
B) As good as the OT (Ep. 4-6)
C) Between ST and OT
D) As good as the ST (Ep. 7)
E) Between the PT and ST
F) As good as the PT (Ep. 1-3)
G) Worst film in the series
H) Other: _____________


I'll say "D" personally: Comparable in quality to TFA (slightly lower for me), but not on the level of the Original Trilogy.

You?

reply

I'll take "D" for $800, Pat!

reply

Solid "B" for me.....loved R1!!! Showed so much more of the SW universe.

reply

B.

The first Star Wars movie outside of the original trilogy that actually served to enhance it and didn't take anything away from it
How you can make the world a better place:
Don't shop at Wal-Mart.

reply

Really enjoyed it!

"Time is the fire in which we burn."

reply

Worst of the series if you have any reasonable intelligence.

reply

A

reply

C) Between ST and OT
^This, to keep it simple. I'm sure it is slightly more complicated, though.

reply

H) As good as all the other seven Star Wars films.


It's laughable to believe in the notion that any one of the eras are better than the others. All eight films are flawed, but excellent in spite of any flaws. Each film oozes the same tangible magic and spirit of the Star Wars universe.

reply

It's laughable to believe in the notion that any one of the eras are better than the others.


Why is it laughable for people to have a different opinion than you?



Why Star Wars: The Force Awakens' a poorly-made film: https://youtu.be/8g9cJ5WKZeU

reply