MovieChat Forums > And Then There Were None (2015) Discussion > Did this remind anyone of "Saw"? *SPOILE...

Did this remind anyone of "Saw"? *SPOILERS*


An old man with terminal cancer becomes a cerebral vigilante, rounding up a group of sinners and playing them off with twisted mind games before their untimely demise.

OK, granted there are big differences in that ATTWN's victims were murderers whereby not all of Saw's victims were, and that Saw's victims at least had a chance to save themselves. But the premise is still essentially the same.

Charles Dance even looks and acts uncannily like Jigsaw with his cold-blooded, emotionless view to his rationale of meting out justice!

reply

I never saw "Saw" so I can't comment on the similarities but I'm sure someone will.

I will say though that this novel is generally believed to be the prototype for the modern day slasher films - i.e. small group of people in a confined space murdered systematically with the murderer unknown until the end - a genre Saw belongs to. I don't usually like horror/occult/slasher type films so I'm only superficially familiar with many of them. I read And There Were None when it was called Ten Little Indians many years ago as a teenager. I remember liking the book but can honestly say I only watched this series because Aidan Turner was in it. I'm glad I did as everyone (cast and production) was excellent.

reply

I read And There Were None when it was called Ten Little Indians many years ago as a teenager.


Does anyone know why the title was changed?

reply

Because Ten Little Native American's wasn't as catchy. At least it was better than the original title Ten Little N**g**s. And Then There Was None doesn't offend any particular group although it is a spoiler for the ending.

reply

OMG re: original title. I mean, if Agatha were a Rap artist the title would be okay.

reply

LOL, amazing how that works, isn't it.

reply

That's because Agatha Christie's original novel was a groundbreaking achievement. It established a whole genre of psychological thrillers and horror movies decades before this genre would spill over into films.

reply

[deleted]

The other way round, friend :)

Like the other posters said, the source material was a groundbreaking masterpiece which established a very specific genre that Saw and other movies like it would follow decades later.

Never seen Saw but from what you describe it sounds like a direct homage to ATTWN.


___

"If people were to know of the things that I know, it would all fall apart..."

reply

Same thing crossed my mind! I wondered if the makers of SAW had read the book. I'm sure this plot device has been used in other things I've seen as well.

It's too cerebral! We're trying to make a movie here, not a film!

reply

Not really, I didn't think of it.

reply

The production notes for the Saw page in Wikipedia doesn't mention ATTWN at all. However, I must confess to not having read the Agatha Christie novel. Was the ending in the TV show the same as in the book?

reply

Yes, it did.

reply