MovieChat Forums > Smile 2 (2024) Discussion > For anyone that liked the original, how ...

For anyone that liked the original, how does this one stack up?


I thought the original was pretty good. Is this one better, worse, around the same?

UPDATE: Just got back and loved it! Definitely better than the original imo. Thank you all for the suggestions!

reply

I thought this was one was better. It is intense, creepy and twisted. The only complaint I have is it uses a lot of loud jump scares.

reply

Good to know. I think I'll give it a watch. Thanks!

reply

Downsides for me:
Counted about 6 jump scares in the first 30 minutes. My cinema was loud so got a bit tiresome where I'm jumping because of the noise and not the thing on screen.

A few jump scares were a bit hackneyed. Seen them play out before. It got more creative later on though.

Some of the CGI blood and gore was a bit silly.

The drug dealer killing himself with a dumbbell I found silly.

Protagonist doesn't tell anybody what she's experiencing. No explanations to anybody.

Other than that it was great. They at least tried to do more than jump scares later on. The story was a good one and the actress fantastic.

reply

I really liked the original, and I thought this one was a little better. There was a noticeable increase in the budget this time around, and it seemed to be well used.

I agree with swishin48 about the overreliance on jump scares. My only other complaint is the length of the film; they could have easily cut 20 minutes from the middle, and the story wouldn’t have changed.

That said, I liked this film a lot, and Naomi Scott was really great in it. 8/10.

reply

Just got back. You're spot on. Some of that extra footage could've been used for a Director's Cut edition but didn't turn me off from really enjoying this. Idk if you noticed but another small nitpick was the CGI (broken glass at the recovery center + end scene to name a few). But yeah...probably my favorite horror movie of 2024!

reply

Nice to see all these comments! I enjoyed the first one - looking forward to catching this one.

reply

The synergy on this board gives me faint reminders of IMDB back in the day. Definitely give it a watch! It was awesome!

reply

👍 👍

reply

💯

reply