Casting in movie roles is not really the same thing as hiring in a regular job
In a regular job it is damn well racist to discriminate based on race, because obviously a white guy and a black guy can be equally good at engineering or being a nurse or whatever
But in acting it's different. Daniel Day-Lewis may be the best actor in the world, but he is obviously not fit to play MLK jr. or Django in Django Unchained. Jordan Peele writes, directs, and produces his movies. He takes on the brunt of the creative work, his movies are his visions. You can't tell an artist what kinds of characters or stories they want to create
If he wants to make movies that aim to speak to black people, then he has the right to do that. And it wouldn't make sense in that case to cast a white lead
Is anyone butthurt that Tyler Perry makes only movies for black people? No, nobody cares because A) his movies suck and B) your average white person has no interest in watching them. But white people care about Jordan Peele's casting choices because they find his movies intriguing. But he still has a right to write black characters, who then must logically be played by black actors
Not all movies work like that. Some movies are written by one guy, produced by a second guy, directed by a third guy, and cast by a fourth guy. If the casting director takes it upon him or herself to single out one race and only consider that one race, without basing that decision on any creative decisions made by the writers, producers, or directors, then yes that could very well be said to be racist
reply
share