Who didn't like Luke Skywalker at all?


He was so grumpy and conflicted and then manipulative that I didn't really care when he left.

reply

I'm OK with the grumpy part, my problem is with the "murder people in their sleep (and fail)" part.




reply

Yep, cause all Jed become grumpy when they are old. Lets remember the amazing scene when Yoda threw his choopers at Luke when he didnt lifted the X-Wing! Or when Obi Wan yelled about the lazy youth of today while fighting the sand people alone. Making a Jedi grumpy is the most stupid idea ever done. They are Jedis. Theres no way for them to get grumpy. Its just another trial to let heroes become ordinary, so that we dont feel as worthless.

reply

Who didn't like Luke Skywalker at all?


Well, it did not appear Kylo Ren was a fan.

Or Snoke

reply

That wasn’t Luke and TLJ wasn’t Star Wars.

reply

Yes, it was, whether you like it or not.

reply

Nope, it wasnt. It wasnt Star Wars at all. It was just a rofit centre for Disney with the Star Wars label. Learn to live with it. You remember the hatred over Phantom Menace? This wont be even part of the hatred brought to Last Jedi. Disney killed its label now at the big budget market. What we gonna see from now on are movies with way smaller income at the cinemas.

reply

No, it’s something else. If you liked it, great.

reply

You have Lucas Star Wars and Disney Star Wars, they are two totally different things.

reply

Yep, the name was Jake Skywalker. The grumpy part of the Skywalker family ;) .

reply

Luke Skywalker? Wasnt that the guy that won with the rebels against the empire?

Or do you mean Jake Skywalker? This grumpy guy which wasnt a Jedi at all. So noone gave a damn about him.

reply

He’d given up on the force, and finds it again in the end, this is text book screen writing, creating a character arc. They need to fix themselves before they can fix other things.

reply