Isn't this really racist?


I mean come on, people. It's one thing to say "Hey, native people aren't childlike saintly beings wandering the forests." but it's hardly the point of satire to demonize them either. Furthermore it seems to attack a strawman. I've never heard of liberal college kids getting excited for a cause who defend cannibal cultures (to the extent any exist anymore). As far as I know the only true cannibal societies existed in Polynesia and Hawaii, and even then it was generally ritualistic.

---
Trist on

reply

[deleted]

By your logic, everyone is African.

reply

If that’s how you feel, then you should not watch Apocalypto. Both movies portray the truth, that some/many pre-Colombian South American tribes were quite brutal and had very nasty rituals including cannibalism and sacrifice. That’s not racist; it’s factual.

Also, the group did not know the tribe was cannibalistic; if they had, most of them would never have gone there. If you were referring specifically to the ending, I explained why she protected them in this thread: http://www.imdb.com/title/tt2403021/board/nest/251812440?d=253058498#253058498




(Response notification is off.)

reply

Yes, yes it is.

My film collection: http://6travisjohnson.filmaf.com/owned

reply

I don't think it's racist because it's not supposed to be any kind of ACTUAL statement on the people living in the Amazon Basin. It's really just an homage to Italian-made third world cannibal movies.

Similarly though, I don't think it's meant to be some stupid right-wing statement about "social justice warriors". That is just a convenient plot device. Everybody knows college students can be naive and simplistic and even at times be sanctimonious a-holes, like SOME of the more obnoxious characters in this movie. But look at their "critics", who want to round up 15 million people in America who actually work hard (as opposed to sitting on their ass collecting Social Security and disability while watching Fox Mews and whining about how the country is going to hell). They want to dump all these people in Mexico, even though it'll probably destroy several US industries that depend on their labor. Then they're going to build a great big expensive wall along the entire border to stop them from returning and somehow get Mexico to pay for it, which they'll gladly do I'm sure after you send them into major recession by dumping 15 million now-unemployed into their country.

The point is if you're incredibly simplistic and naive, but idealistic, you're a "social justice warrior", but if you're incredibly simplistic and HATE-FILLED and blame all your problems on convenient scapegoats, that's so much better. Makes you wonder who the real cannibals should really be chowing down on.

"Let be be finale of seem/ The only emperor is the Emperor of Ice Cream"

reply

One word for left wing commies:

Trigglypuff

Go touch yourselves over cocoa as you plan to save the world.

reply

Not racist at all.

reply

No.

reply