Not a single redeeming quality about AoT Live Action

You are absolutly right about the terrible effects. They take you out of the movie. But I have to say the tone of the movie is really good. The first attack was hard to look at. Very depressing and scary in a ugly way. But overall to cheap looking movie for 2015. Even from Japan.

I thought the movie was decent, and while i thought the Titans were pretty creepy (specifically the baby one) the colossal Titan looked too fake for me. I mean i don't expect oscar worthy effects or anything, but that did take me out of the moment when he showed up. Everything else about the first attack was well done for me.

Also what the *beep* at the dude who could toss the titan, and why the hell didn't he use that more often. And while i liked sasha, her using the bow was retarded.

did laugh at eren getting cockblocked by the titan though.

100% agreed on the comments the effects weren't great on the collousal Titan but I thought the rest was pretty decent, and the fight at the end when eren was going through those Titans was pretty cool. I'd give it a 6-7/10 will definetly be watching part 2

Loved it! Titans were creepy and scary, the 3D gear was slick, and can't wait for the second movie.

Did you expect a 26 movie release so it could cover every tiny detail in the manga? It's a companion to the manga and anime, Titan's made real. Awesome.

- IMHO...Movies last 10 years keep getting blander, TV Shows keep getting better.

Well considering many have viewed this as a Live action NOT for fans. Which although as fan, is smart. Let's be honest, any 90 minute live action for just about any big anime would fall short so why bother. If anything this might attract more people to the anime. Anecdotal, but I have a few friends who don't watch anime, but after watching are giving it a go. Success in my book.

Also, the title is complete grammatical nonsense. There is no attack on the moon Titan.

The movie was quite bad, but I have to say that I rather liked the look of the Titans. But that was perhaps the only good thing about the movie.

Oh I love how everyone is commenting on the LOOKS, the CGI, and the ACTION... Like it was SUPPOSED to be another cheap and retarded summer flick with all flash and no substance. Which it definitely wound up as, and that's MY problem with it. It's NOT okay. The anime itself (and the manga, of course) is a fine drama, it's clever and horrifying and it doesn't draw its awesomeness from jump scares, gore, overacting or infantile jealousy. It deals with courage and fear, desperation and ignorance, greed and corruption, friendship and trust, family and responsibility, perseverance, discrimination, animal instincts and all the monsters inside our minds. It's deep as *beep*. The movie captured nearly none of that. And if you say there wasn't enough time, well, they could've very well made it TWICE AS LONG. Yes, movies can be 3 hours long. And they can have more than 3 parts. And they're largely pointless if based on games or manga+anime, but can still be successful; eg. live action Death Note is quite bearable, even though more than half of it was cut. AoT just isn't.