Best scene


The best scene for me by far was the dinner date between Brandon and Marianne.

It showed just the awkwardness of dating, first dates in particular, quite rare in film & television to be shown so frankly. The brief moments of silence between finding things to say, bemused expressions, nervous laughter, walking the streets afterwards, talking about absolutely nothing merely to have something to say, the awkward goodbye on the steps of the subway station.

The numerous interruptions of the third party, a waiter, played into the scene fantastically, I felt as a viewer to be not watching a film at all, but sitting in a restaurant, invisible, privy to a brief moment in the lives of these two people at their most vulnerable amidst the minutiae of everyday life.

When the waiter comes to pour the wine, Marianne is asking Brandon what his longest relationship has been. Brandon hesitates, the waiter begins to pour, stops, Brandon notices and motions him to continue. Almost as though the waiter, having detected the personal nature of the question, finds himself intruding and begins to withdraw his presence. Was such a thing planned, one wonders...

Pitch perfect.

reply

Best scene for me was the conversation scene between the siblings ... Thought it was pretty powerful & i really felt for the characters. Sad.

reply

Best scene for me was Carey Mulligan singing New York, New York.
Priceless.

reply

He wasn't even gentlemanly enough to ask Marianne first what she wanted, he always placed his order first. 



reply

You're kidding, right? He waited till she ordered the lamb, then copied her order, because he evidently wasn't particularly interested in the food. He didn't order anything else except the wine, the waiter's previous suggestion, which she had expressed no opinion on.

reply

I'd say the sex scene between Brandon and Marianne was at least equally good. Painful to watch, because you can see the potential, and then how far apart they get in a matter of seconds. There are a hundred ways to salvage that situation if you have the slightest clue about normal human interactions, about connecting with another human being you like, and it's appallingly clear to both us and Marianne that Brandon has none.

reply

It's a subtly-made movie and, therefore, has many eye-catching scenes (especially considering the great role-playing of Fassbender being there throughout the film).
However, I believe the scene involving the last dialogue between the leading roles were superbly functional and explanatory [and, so to say, the best]. The key word in this scene and in the whole movie is 'trap' (of course, besides the cause of trap, i.e. 'shame'). And that's the concept developing the narrative when Brandon gets [more and more] trapped into a web of social [antagonistic] interactions which are nourishing from, and catering to, power relations.

reply

Any time Carey Mulligan was naked and that scene when she crawls into bed and tries to help Fassbender masturbate. I love her body. I don't care if she was playing his sister.

reply

The voicemail: "We're not bad people. We just come from a bad place."

Something about that always stuck with me.

reply

Thanks purplish-1

That line stuck with me too, so I tried to forget it.
But, thank you for making me remember it - I needed to😞

But even if you come from a bad place, you can always invoke the words of James Cameron:

The future is not set. There is no fate but what we make for ourselves.
🙌

reply

Totally agree with you, this was a fabulous scene.

reply

dimsung_09 -

reply