I need to watch All Star again before I can say. Which one do you prefer?
shareThey both have their strengths and weaknesses.
Allstar had the great scene with Lex and Clark during the prison escape.
Straightedge means I'm better than you.
Finally saw this one. It's so far superior to Doomsday it's laughable. I think this is better than any of the *live-action* Superman movies. It actually instilled a sense of wonder at the Superman world, and made me care about him and Lois as I never had.
shareAll star is the worst Superman movie ever.
share