MovieChat Forums > War Horse (2011) Discussion > Does Anyone Like This Movie?

Does Anyone Like This Movie?


I didn't think I was going to like this at all because I thought it looked really corny but I ended up loving it. It had a really good story, good actors, and great cinematography. I not a big horse person, (I'm not even much of an animal person) but I loved this. I don't know why people keep saying that it was awful and it's only for animal lovers. Give me your thoughts.

reply

It was ok. I was expecting to be more moved than I was and to be crying a heck of a lot more so maybe it wasn't as schmalzy as I was expecting.

George Clooney fansite, news & gossip updated daily: www.clooneysopenhouse.com, www.facebook.com/clooneysopenhouse and www.twitter.com/clooneysopenhse

reply

The horses were better actors than the people. I was seriously impressed with some of the horse acting, but equally disappointed in some of the human acting.

reply

Spielberg always delivers a good story. What I usually find is that I can't bear the emotional tone of his films. I surprised myself with this in that, despite the schmaltz, I loved the story of the horses which seemed emotionally authentic in a way that the surrounding story was not and I could put aside the usual 'tugging at the heart strings' to feel what it's like to see a war from another perspective - that of an animal in servitude. The best scene is where the horse bolts into 'no man's land' and gets ensnared by the wire. There are lots of good scenes before this one though.

A woman can be any shape she wants.
What about a hexagon?

reply

I really liked it and I liked the acting, I love Tom Hidddlston and thought he did a great job. I thought the movie could have been cut some but other than that it was good.

reply

Hell no

reply

From the previews, I was expecting more action. My eyelids got heavier and heavier as the horse got passed around. I think the development of wild horse to farm mule could have been done in much shorter time without losing effectiveness, leaving more time for action.

Yes, the title character is a horse but it's not a talking animal movie so people still need to carry the load.

reply

I'd give it a B-.
I thought it dragged on too long.

reply

Excellent movie!

reply

I admit I didn't want to watch it at first but I'm so happy I did! It turned out to be such a sad yet wonderful movie!

reply

It was dumb as hell, but I liked it. It's just another stupid family drama where you need to check your brain at the door.

reply