MovieChat Forums > Disappeared (2009) Discussion > Cases where it's obvious who did it, but...

Cases where it's obvious who did it, but they just can't 'prove' it?


I love this show, but one thing that frustrates me so much are the cases where:

a.) it's obvious foul play was involved
b.) it's obvious who is responsible

...but the police don't have enough "concrete" evidence to bring the suspects to justice. I can think of two right off the bat:

-The Mike Williams case, about the hunter in north Florida who mysteriously went missing from his boat, then his greedy wife throws together a rushed memorial service, cashes in on his life insurance, marries her dead husband's best friend, and lawyers up. Yep, a total mystery there!

-The Mandy Stokes case, about the young woman going to grad school in California whose lowlife brother was seen fighting with her before she vanished. He used her credit cards right after she went missing, and acted nervous and jittery around investigators. This one isn't as clear-cut, but it's obvious the brother is involved *somehow* yet he just gets to hang out and go on with his life. So frustrating!

Any other episodes like these?

reply

I would definitely say the case about Terrance Williams and Felipe Santos. Both men disappeared within a few months of each other and Deputy Calkins was the last person to see either of them. He also lied about having contact with Terrance on dispatch, but witnesses saw them together. The officer also said he dropped both men off at Circle-K, which is just too much of a coincidence. He's still the prime suspect, but they just don't have enough evidence to nail him. It's frustrating.

reply

It's so obvious the cop had something to do with the disappearance of both Terrance Williams and Felipe Santos. I can only imagine the frustration of the families of these two victims in not being able to see justice prevail.

The John Spira case is another one where I think it's obvious his wife and business partner had something to do with his disappearance. Both of them refused to cooperate with the police. His wife died 3 years after him, supposedly of a heart ailment, but John's sister believes it was suicide. She had attempted suicide before.

reply

The case of Patty Vaughan, at least as presented by Disappeared, points strongly to her estranged husband Jerry Ray "JR" Vaughan. The family indicates there was domestic abuse according to reports on the internet. The show mentions possible blood &/or bleach cleaner in the home and her vehicle.

I wonder what the 3 children think about the case (their names are Brittany Jayne Vaughan Bohannon, Ray Vaughan, & Andrew Tyler Vaughan). They were raised by their father after their mother's disappearance and were moved to various states, not having contact with their mother's family. They were in the home the night their mother went missing, but were never allowed to be interviewed by the police.

Here is an interview with Patty's sister http://missingpiecesshow.homestead.com/MissingPiecesEpisode29Archive.html

And a site about Patty's disappearance http://www.pattyvaughan.com

reply

Everyone is bringing up good examples. A lot of these cases are from Texas I've noticed, and they also seem to have really poor law enforcement when it comes to investigating and solving these cases.

The Patty Vaughan case is so disheartening. I wonder as the children get older will they wonder if their father had something to do with it and/or will they have psychological issues. I'm sure he (and his sister) has brainwashed them as to what really happened (both were in the house when they were investigating the home too, wth?). He has been in control of everything one of the friends/family pointed out on the show.

Roxanne Paltauf hasn't been mentioned, and it's obvious her then boyfriend was involved. The show even mentioned he threatened another girlfriend and made reference to Roxanne's disappearance.

Tina McQuaig was reported to be having an affair according to her friends, with her neighbor and her body was found near where he worked. He also tried to use products to make him pass the polygraph which he failed. He wasn't around when they were searching for her, and he and his wife have since divorced and moved away. Unfortunately, no physical evidence was found linking him to her homicide.

It's sad, a lot of these women go missing simply because of the boyfriend/husband/man they are romantically involved with. It's also scary how many men are out there who are capable of bringing harm to women.

reply

Roxanne Paltauf hasn't been mentioned, and it's obvious her then boyfriend was involved.


Truly heartbreaking story. Why that lovely young girl would get involved with someone with Warning! Danger! signs all over his life--heartbreaking. Another one that broke my heart is of the young college girl in New York who was somewhat plain, didn't live a risky lifestyle at all, dated some bookish type--and then disappeared. Her parents' agony always brings me to tears, and I wish I could remember her name. Terrance Williams is another heartbreaker. Heck, they all are.

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

http://missingpiecesshow.homestead.com/MissingPiecesEpisode29Archive.html

http://www.pattyvaughan.com

to make links clickable...click on the word Link up above that is underlined..copy then paste your link in beytween the [ brackets

reply

[deleted]

Definitely "Crime and Punishment". The deputy in this case is full of sh!t. He's a criminal with a badge and a gun, and he probably used both in the case of Terrance Williams, in a secluded area, away from the police car, to avoid evidence being found. I wonder if that was ever suspected. I mean come on, law enforcement can be just as foul as your average criminal. There are people who join the system just to beat it, and that's already evident enough, in the disappearance of Terrance Williams. Who knows what was done to him or the other guy, who was suspected of disappearing because of the same deputy. Chances are, both cases were done the same, and I really hope there was enough consideration from law enforcement, as to what a fellow member could've possibly done to cover his tracks.

reply

I only started watching disappeared but this case is so frustrating and I believe finance hindered this investigation. The case was sloppy and the female lead detective was pathetic , her family did more and said the right things yet dealing with this case when her fiance was still in the country they could have had him even on suspicion. Theory, they dropped the ball.

DODGE THIS!!!!!

reply

sloppygun - which case are you talking about?

reply

The episode with the young mother in Florida, Lucely 'Lilly' Arambaro (think that was her last name.) Anyways, it's so obvious it was that loser boyfriend of hers. They just don't have any evidence, no body, nothing to prove it. The guy is a thug loser and it's scary to think this young woman moved her baby in with this monster. Then she goes off to a crack house, and allows drug parties at her house. I'm not judging this woman, I didn't know her, but from what we saw, it's pretty obvious, loser changes his story too many times. It's really sad the mother couldn't do more for her daughter until after she went missing. A hunger strike will not bring your daughter back unfortunately, and it didn't help in solving the case. This young woman took a wrong turn in life and it's sad her son is growing up without her.

Knock if off Napolean make yourself a dang quesadil-la!

reply

As well as the ones mentioned so far, the Bethany Decker case is maddening. Very obvious the boyfriend Ronald almost certainly had something to do with it. Violent and controlling and the last time anyone other than him saw her was when she was in a hurry to get back home to him before "things got bad" It drives me crazy seeing these people not being pursued as much as they should be!

reply

The one where the woman walked off into the woods. I think her husband is involved in some way. His alabis all check, but he failed his polygraph and seemed to have a contract/agreement with the cops not to talk about details of the case to Disappeared. He and the cops all seemed to be hiding information. Actually no. Not seemed. They were. They'd flat out say "oh yeah this...but I'm allowed to talk about that." Or "I don't want to discuss that." It was very bizzare. But she was depressed and was cheating on him with numerous men. I think he definitely had something to do with it

---
"Chaos is what killed the dinosaurs, darling."

reply

I think we can add robert hoagland to this list...the druggie son at the time looks really suspicious (he is clean and has a job now).....

he was living with his dad who hid the car keys, son was arrested driving his dads car.....dad confronted the other drug people after his son took the lap tops there and they SUPPOSEDLY went missing...

reply

Suzy Lyall - all clues point to the creepy, possessive ex boyfriend. It's been 18 years, but the police should re-question him.

reply

Suzy Lyall - all clues point to the creepy, possessive ex boyfriend. It's been 18 years, but the police should re-question him.


Yes! I don't know why I keep forgetting this young girl's name, when her mom's and dad's heartbreak was the first "Disappeared" that made me break down and cry.

In regard to the original post/thread topic: "Disappeared" might be trying to return to featuring sincerely puzzling cases. Bryce Laspisa (sp?) and Rico Harris, Robert Hoagland, Jessica Heeringa--every case this season (7) is puzzling. I just wish they would get the original narrator back and, if the original writers have left, I wish they'd get them back too. It's awful to say that "Disappeared" early season episodes were often terrifying (Maura Murray) or eerie (Leah Roberts) to the point where the mystery element became almost entertaining. Almost. I feel so guilty for even writing the words, but if heightening the drama of a disappearance, making tragic and unresolved vanishings more theatrical, can possibly contribute to the missing people being found...then maybe keeping the narration and presentation so suspenseful could help.

The most important thing of all is giving the families, especially the parents, a national forum in which the b*st*rds who kidnapped or killed their loved ones will be hounded hopefully until the day they get the punishment they deserve. The parents and families are always--every one of them--heartbreaking. Even the close friends. I recall the episode where that poor soul in Philadelphia actually asked to take a lie detector test to prove she was innocent of involvement in her best friend's (a nurse's) disappearance in Camden.

reply